Sonic Megathread

[ThunderBoy]

 

[Jayonnaise6105 Jayonnaise6105]

Not sure why, but something about this collection of legally distinct and non-specific characters made me feel compelled to post this in the Sonic thread

Manga: Joshiraku

 

[Ikagura]

In a better timeline we would've gotten a second Mania game and a Classic Sonic movie animated in this style.

 

[Tonberry]

October is spooky season!

 

[ThunderBoy]

 

[Deleted member 58254]

I wish the sonic franchise had as much spin offs as the Mario franchise

They literally have so many characters they could flesh out I don't understand why Sega doesn't do it

 

[Cloudh20]

I would like a Mario and Sonic crossover that was an RPG.

 

[UnDubious]

A proper Sonic RPG when the series was still cool would have been great. Like around the time of Super Mario RPG, maybe a late Genesis or Saturn game. Other than that, I disagree. Sega not just doing the same damn franchises over and over is one of the things I prefer them over Nintendo for.

 

[TinRattler]

Sonic vs Mario kart

 

[Matricks]

Because Sonic is an animal and kinda boring as rpg character, no princess to save etc, otherwise tgere would be a flood spinoffs, it just doesnt sale.

 

[TinRattler]

Because Sonic is an animal and kinda boring as rpg character, no princess to save etc, otherwise tgere would be a flood spinoffs, it just doesnt sale.

Mario is a fat smelly Italian plumber who does the same thing over and over again. Mario is a cult brainwashed the masses

 

[Ikagura]

I wish the sonic franchise had as much spin offs as the Mario franchise.

The issue is that historically, for each idea Sonic tried, the Mario equivalent was much, much better.

Sonic Chronicles failed as a RPG where Mario thrived with Paper Mario and Mario & Luigi.

Sonic's early racing games paled in comparison of Mario Kart. Sure, All-Star Racing and its sequels were good but it took them almost two decades.

Sonic's attempt at a party game with Shuffle ended up being a failure whereas Mario Party brought hours of fun to people.

Maybe the only time Sonic did it better was Sonic Pinball Party vs Super Mario Ball but that was a mere flipper game.

Post automatically merged: Oct 8, 2025

Sega not just doing the same damn franchises over and over is one of the things I prefer them over Nintendo for.

I'd beg to differ though.

Sega is often doing Sonic, Yakuza and Persona games around while barely remembering their older IPs.

Yes, we had SoR 4 then a new Shinobi game but how many years after? Sure they've finally announced a new Jet Set Radio, Golden Axe, SoR and Crazy Taxi game recently as well but we've waited over a decade (not counting mobile game spinoffs like the Crazy Taxi one).

And Nintendo is also bringing new IP to the table (Drag X Drive being one) as well as bringing back older IPs from time to time (such as Famicom Detective Club) so that's a bit disingenuous to assume one doesn't do what the other is also doing.

PS: Actually I'm tired of Sega milking Sonic and making spin-offs instead of bringing back older IPs would hurt more.

 

[UnDubious]

Sega is often doing Sonic, Yakuza and Persona games around while barely remembering their older IPs.

(...)

Persona is Atlus. Sega owns Atlus but it's still its own company that does its own thing under Sega, and it was mostly MegaTen since before Sega bought them.
Yakuza and Sonic are their two cash cows now so they have to keep them going. It doesn't change the fact that through their history they were always much more into doing the new thing than keeping every series going together.

 

[bjork]

They were apparently going to do this with grand plans for all sorts of Sonic-related spinoffs after the splash Sonic 1 made, but then the original Sonic died on Sonic 2sday after accidentally drinking bleach. Tom Kalinske hustled to find a lookalike, and that's why Sonic looks different in part 3. But he never quite got as much love as the original Sonic, and so when Spinball came out and was abysmal, the other spinoff projects were all done as tax write-offs for loss of income. Sorry.

 

[Ikagura]

Persona is Atlus. Sega owns Atlus but it's still its own company that does its own thing under Sega, and it was mostly MegaTen since before Sega bought them.

A second party company I understand. But then you could argue that Fire Emblem is Intelligent Systems, Kirby Hal Laboratory and Pokémon GameFreaks. Should second party games be counted or not?

Still: Persona is, above Megami Tensei, the IP that gave them quite a lot of funds to Sega.

Yakuza and Sonic are their two cash cows now so they have to keep them going. It doesn't change the fact that through their history they were always much more into doing the new thing than keeping every series going together.

Why should it matter by the way? At the end of the day it's the quality of the games as well as the ideas themselves that count.

Sega replaced Sakura Wars by Valkyria Chronicles but fundamentally both are strategy games with a focus on story. Shining as a franchise (including Force) got slowly eclipsed by Sakura Wars as well.

I'd also argue that despite using the same IPs you can see a difference between old Zelda games and new ones or even how much variety Mario as an IP has brought (the only series that kept it too safe and bland could be the later two NSMB games).

In fact people would rather see a comeback of older Nintendo IPs they haven't used in a while (like Kid Icarus). Same with Sega until recently with their announcement.

But we're digressing a bit there. Sonic having more spin-offs goes against what you said about wanting more novelty as well.

 

[UnDubious]

A second party company I understand. But then you could argue that Fire Emblem is Intelligent Systems, Kirby Hal Laboratory and Pokémon GameFreaks. Should second party games be counted or not?

Still: Persona is, above Megami Tensei, the IP that gave them quite a lot of funds to Sega.


Why should it matter by the way? At the end of the day it's the quality of the games as well as the ideas themselves that count.

Sega replaced Sakura Wars by Valkyria Chronicles but fundamentally both are strategy games with a focus on story. Shining as a franchise (including Force) got slowly eclipsed by Sakura Wars as well.

I'd also argue that despite using the same IPs you can see a difference between old Zelda games and new ones or even how much variety Mario as an IP has brought (the only series that kept it too safe and bland could be the later two NSMB games).

In fact people would rather see a comeback of older Nintendo IPs they haven't used in a while (like Kid Icarus). Same with Sega until recently with their announcement.

But we're digressing a bit there. Sonic having more spin-offs goes against what you said about wanting more novelty as well.

Yes, I don't want more Sonic spin-off, that's what I said. A RPG in the mid 90s could have been cool though.
Valkyria Chronicles isn't really like Sakura Wars, and neither is like Shining Force. You're playing it very loose there to make that point. And Persona is a Megami Tensei spin-off, so it's still MegaTen.

 

[Ikagura]

Valkyria Chronicles isn't really like Sakura Wars, and neither is like Shining Force. You're playing it very loose there to make that point.

Okay, we can agree that these strategy game series are different but so are Nintendo platformer series or how several of their have evolved and changed through time.

And Persona is a Megami Tensei spin-off, so it's still MegaTen.

My point was that the "Sega does new stuff unlike Nintendo" argument cannot be really applied when even Sega loves reusing the same IPs as well.

 

[MajesticSiN]

I feel like the Sonic franchise has already dipped it's toes in a bunch of spin off games.
I wouldn't mind more though.

 

[Ikagura]

I feel like the Sonic franchise has already dipped it's toes in a bunch of spin off games.
I wouldn't mind more though.

I want actually good ones.

 

[Matricks]

 

[MajesticSiN]

I want actually good ones.

I talked with my uncle who works at Sega and he said no.

 

[Evaccaneer Doom]

We all do
Yes WE, you and I
WE want another Sonic Rush, a modern way of playing Sonic Advance + Battle, Sonic 3D Blast, Sonic R 2, and Sonic Labyrinth with Tails this time

 

[Soma_Shotgun]

I would like them to make actually good games first lol

 

[Advil Lavs]

I wish there was a good Sonic RPG

 

[Ikagura]

I would like them to make actually good games first lol.

They are already doing btw.

Just that they don't need to aim to be AAA.

I wish there was a good Sonic RPG.

It's not Sonic but Project X Zone is a great Sega + Namco + Capcom crossover RPG.