Hot takes

than people saying "[insert hated/less popular game in a series] is actually not bad/pretty good and deserves some recognition".
I got one of those takes, Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Gates to Infinity is actually one of the best pokemon games of all time and all the reasons people don't like it were superficial surface reasons.


great story and characters with classic mystery dungeon gameplay, truly underrated and overhated
 
I got one of those takes, Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Gates to Infinity is actually one of the best pokemon games of all time and all the reasons people don't like it were superficial surface reasons.


great story and characters with classic mystery dungeon gameplay, truly underrated and overhated
Seeing the current state of the franchise, the Mystery Dungeon Tetralogy (counting the remake as the same entry as the first game and the Wiiware entries as non canon spinoffs) is probably the best thing to have happened to it.

I also think the Rumble sub-series is good in its own regard (and I wish we got a proper Action RPG spinoff).

PS: I don't vibe with Pokken (then again I'm not a huge Tekken fan outside of the PSX era and 4) and think that there should've been a 2D entry like the fangame Type: Wild
1759488433336.jpeg
 
All you people that think Final Fantasy VII is great are living in dreamland. Pure junk.

View attachment 115572

Ruby is worse than Emerald because Emerald has a simple but tedious path to victory. You have plenty of time to go to the bathroom and get snacks while knights of the round+quadra gets mimed over and over. After you run out of that you can just beat him to death. The less materia you equip the less damage aire tam storm does. I didn't even have or know about the underwater materia until years later and the timer wasn't a big problem.

Ruby is just a troll. knights of the round causes him to counter with ultima so you are stuck with Bahamut Zero. You better have enough ribbons and you better enter that battle with two dead party members because he'll use whirlsand to single out his prey.
 
Asking for a remake of 99 percent of games is spiritually equivalent of jacking it to Simpsons porn, and that one percent will never get the remake it needs because the game was probably awful but had very interesting concepts held back by production issues and as such sold so poorly that you couldn't financially justify going back to the well.

The Souls series is coworker core gaming and its overall reception will not age nearly as well as you'd expect given its current reputation. I'm glad everyone at From is still getting a paycheck but whenever I hear someone irl talk about that game, my eyes glaze over. The series for those people with the tired Link with a coffee avatars. If the combat was even slightly worth a damn, we'd see more organized PvP beyond fight clubs that require enough ruleset changes to make Smogon blush.

Final Fantasy IX is a 4/5 JRPG but a rancid Final Fantasy game, and it reflects very poorly on you if that's your favorite in the series. It should have stayed a spinoff.

"""New""" takes on preexisting skill based genres like rhythm games, shmups or pinball almost always display a fundamental misunderstanding of what makes those genres interesting. I don't need the 20th "oh this pinball game is actually an action adventure platformer with blah blah blah", why don't you just make a good fucking table and have the depth of play come from that instead of having to tack on as many bells and whistles as you can in order to make up for the fact that you don't understand a genre.

In no other genre has the bag been fumbled harder than RTS games. It really shouldn't be this hard to have a viable starcraft knockoff out and about by now.

Parries in fighting games lead to bad habits and that gameplay scenario where both players walk back and forward for 30 seconds without wanting to press a button because they don't want to get blown the fuck out by someone fishing for the parry. It also encourages players to gamble on very risky options becuase the reward could be greater than just down backing. The GGXX's series take on parries (slashback) prevents this issue because it's prohibitively hard. This is not me saying "take parries out of 3rd Strike", or any game that currently has them in it because that's part of their gamelay design and people do enjoy it, but like, it's something I wouldn't want to see as much going forward.

Speaking of Gear, most Sol Badguy players don't wash their asshole and are not very good at the game.

More games should appeal to a younger crowd. Gaming switching its focus from a medium where anyone can pick it up to something that costs too much for the average child to enjoy is a death sentence for the future of the medium. If it continues, there will come a time where the only people who play video games are 40+, and the themes of games will be changed to appeal to that crowd, in the same way you see Terminator/Robocop/other 80s ephemera shoved into media because it's what appeals to the only target demo with disposable income left.

Psychonauts didn't age well. Tim Schafer is a hack fraud. I didn't care for Grim Fandango, either.
 
If a 100% makes you sick of the game, then it isn't fun to get, just beat the game if you want how you want instead of fighting for a simple number
 
All you people that think Final Fantasy VII is great are living in dreamland. Pure junk.

View attachment 115572
I will always stand by my principles and say "FFVI is the best one" and rest my case, yeah the rest are great but VI was the peak for me, it was and still is the best experience playing a Final Fantasy title for me, VII will always be "Muh Aerith Death", "Muh Sephiroth One Winged Angel", like everyone points out the same things, in exchange you can point out any town or moment of VI and it will work every time to convince someone to play it, yeah even mentioning Zozo Michigan.
Post automatically merged:

Final Fantasy IX is a 4/5 JRPG but a rancid Final Fantasy game, and it reflects very poorly on you if that's your favorite in the series. It should have stayed a spinoff.
Really? Because for me it was a return to basics with the series, like VII and VIII took a detour to "too much anime" highway and the Fantasy was getting shoved into the side, then along came IX and showed one of the last glimpses at old SquareSoft, you know, back then when they weren't afraid of nothing.
"""New""" takes on preexisting skill based genres like rhythm games, shmups or pinball almost always display a fundamental misunderstanding of what makes those genres interesting. I don't need the 20th "oh this pinball game is actually an action adventure platformer with blah blah blah", why don't you just make a good fucking table and have the depth of play come from that instead of having to tack on as many bells and whistles as you can in order to make up for the fact that you don't understand a genre.
Please nobody show this guy either Vagrant Story or Front Mission: Gun Hazard, or any old experimental game made by Squaresoft or any other dev back then, literally the most interesting games of the past sometimes were mixes of different components of various genres, or do i have to remind you of Parasite Eve (JRPG mixed with some Survival Horror), Symphony of The Night (platformer mixed with rpg elements, that yeah made it easy but nonetheless enjoyable) or Devil May Cry, that literally mixed so many genres that became it's own thing, inventing a new genre called Hack and Slash, the same way Metal evolved from regular rock n roll.
Parries in fighting games lead to bad habits and that gameplay scenario where both players walk back and forward for 30 seconds without wanting to press a button because they don't want to get blown the fuck out by someone fishing for the parry. It also encourages players to gamble on very risky options becuase the reward could be greater than just down backing. The GGXX's series take on parries (slashback) prevents this issue because it's prohibitively hard. This is not me saying "take parries out of 3rd Strike", or any game that currently has them in it because that's part of their gamelay design and people do enjoy it, but like, it's something I wouldn't want to see as much going forward.
I mean, they are common in the big name fighting games like sf6 or garou city of the wolves, but even 2xko dodged that bullet, also there's a thing called pressure, that usually people do to evade the 30 seconds.
More games should appeal to a younger crowd. Gaming switching its focus from a medium where anyone can pick it up to something that costs too much for the average child to enjoy is a death sentence for the future of the medium. If it continues, there will come a time where the only people who play video games are 40+, and the themes of games will be changed to appeal to that crowd, in the same way you see Terminator/Robocop/other 80s ephemera shoved into media because it's what appeals to the only target demo with disposable income left.
You can always wait for a sale and get them at an more efficient price, but appealing to a younger crowd? haven't you seen the state we are currently in? you give them the littlest of inconveniences and they start shouting NERF in any genre, look at Deltarune, Toby Fox nerfed the knight sword hitbox because people were crying too hard. In these cases i like to quote Satoru Iwata in a interview he had in Game Center CX:
"The difficulty in games comes from the developers who tested the games, and if they found something easy to do, then they tried to fix it so the experience could be more enjoyable"
Look at Silksong, just a little diffulty and people are crying. The younger crowd doesn't want to develop any skill or ability, just getting handed victories with little to nonexistent effort.
 
Last edited:

You asked for hot takes.
 
 
Jokes aside: I never found any appeal to the Grand Theft Auto series. I love Vice City visuals and GTA V's gameplay, but everything around it always turned it off to me. I always found San Andreas very boring to look at.
GTA III really grabbed me for being so different at the time. Vice City was like the same game but more polished and with added 80s charm. After that I lost interest in the series.
 
Every game you like is bad and I will scient8fically break down each of the reasons logically and sequentially so that you know why your taste sucks.
 
I’m not sure how many would agree with me on this, but I think The Last of Us, God of War (2018), and other so-called “cinema games” are a big part of why modern gaming lost its soul. I’m really not a fan of how dominant they’ve become in the current console generation.


I’m not discrediting the craft that goes into these games or calling them bad by default. But since the PS3 era — with Uncharted being the likely catalyst — a large share of AAA releases now feel more like Oscar bait than actual games. Titles like Metal Gear Solid had cinematic ambition long before this trend, yet they still kept the essence of gameplay first. In contrast, modern “cinema games” often boil down to walking sims padded with light RPG mechanics, repetitive actions, and shallow interactivity between long cutscenes (like with puzzles to pad out game time).


Maybe that’s a matter of taste, but to me, gameplay has clearly taken the back seat to story and production value. And if that’s the focus, I’d rather watch a film than pay $70 for a movie pretending to be a game.
 
Jokes aside: I never found any appeal to the Grand Theft Auto series. I love Vice City visuals and GTA V's gameplay, but everything around it always turned it off to me. I always found San Andreas very boring to look at.
I liked 3, VC and IV the most. But yeah, the actual combat was never great. The closest Rockstar came to great combat was Max Payne 3 even though I didn't think it was a great Max Payne game. Not sure why they didn't bother bringing it to their open world games.
Post automatically merged:

Every game you like is bad and I will scient8fically break down each of the reasons logically and sequentially so that you know why your taste sucks.
I do think that Alan Wake II is a pretty bad video game. Nice graphics and environments, though.
 
I do think that Alan Wake II is a pretty bad video game. Nice graphics and environments, though.
At least you can find something nice to say about it, despite feeling that it's bad overall. 😁
 
The n64 may have some of the best games of all time but it's overall library is not that great, the console is severely lacking on fighting games and RPGs, and you can't name 100 Nintendo 64 classics without including some average games on the list.
That's not a controversial take. It's facts. I actually would love to see new releases for it like we've seen for other old systems with games like Demons of Asteborg and Goodboy Galaxy
 
I think Mother and Earthbound suck and the only reason they get any attention is because they try so hard to be bizarre and peculiar that they eventually do something weird enough to have someone finally notice.

Like a coworker being so obnoxious that someone inevitably says something to them about it.

It's like a jazz or classical song trying way too hard to be the genre it's attempting to portray. Maybe blues.
 
I liked the first part but yes the second part is bad and very confusing. The only thing that has changed in the second part is the graphics the story is more of a toilet paper.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Connect with us

Support this Site

RGT relies on you to stay afloat. Help covering the site costs and get some pretty Level 7 perks too.

Featured Video

Latest Threads

ADAM+ A modern ColecoVision and Coleco ADAM emulator and development toolkit.

Hello RetroGameTalk community!


I’m excited to announce the release of ADAM+ (also known...
Read more

PCSX2

My favorite Playstation 2 emulator has received a new update and it now works even better...
Read more

Why is the internet the way it is?

Why isn't it like Cowboy Bebop's version, or like any 90s sci-fi movie/show/anime? Why is...
Read more

Interesting facts about me

OMy name is Lod because I like that name.Second interesting fact: I love Portuguese pizza.Third...
Read more

Early access for Timesplitters Rewind is officially live!


It's alive and it's here! The early access covers...
Read more

Online statistics

Members online
89
Guests online
720
Total visitors
809

Forum statistics

Threads
14,940
Messages
361,170
Members
896,025
Latest member
Valvalme

Today's birthdays

Advertisers

Back
Top