I remembered when I first played Yooka-Laylee, I deliberately avoided any reviews or media discussing it as I did not ant my opinion to be influenced by anyone and to avoid any spoilers. After I finished it, I was taken aback by the amount of complaining about it. While I still preferred the N64 Banjo titles over it, I overall found it mostly enjoyable. Some of the complaints reviewers had were just baffling. "Why the stupid gibberish! Should be voice acted!" You know what series this is mean to be a spiritual successor to, right? The gibberish is a big part of the Banjo series identity and I found it charming. "Camera is so bad!" I swear modern game reviewers are hopeless when it comes to 3D platformers, controlling the camera as you are wandering these spaces just comes a second nature when you play as many of these games as I do. There are games both old and new that have way bigger camera issues than YL does. The most baffling was one reviewer saying that using a hub area to access the game's worlds was outdated. What a bizarre statement, reminds me of reviewers during the 5th gen declaring that 2D gaming is dead and marking games down deliberately if they were not 3D. How are hub worlds outdated? Not all 3D games need to be open world for god's sake.
The nice thing is that the biggest complaints I did have about Yooka-Laylee seem to be getting adressed in the remake so I hope this game gets a second chance. Just going through levels and saying to myself "just one more Pagie before I finish" really did capture the feeling of getting lost in the world that the 3D platformers of my youth were so good at doing. The way some people talked about it, you swear they were playing Bubsy 3D, just absolutely overblown reaction.