Your takes on AI art

Y’all can't we all just get along? Think of some religious figure!

There, I solved everything, I await a solution by the end of the day.
 
AI art takes away from the real artist. Even in some cases stealing art from others and morphing it into some other shit. Anyone can get on a AI generator and make "art" then throw it out there as it being their own. I am a artist myself, I really hate it and do not support! ❤️
 
"But couldn't you do the same thing with Vocaloid?" Yes
Y’all can't we all just get along? Think of some religious figure!
Special-K.jpg
 
I already dont like it when cartoons are colored digitally and how physical ink pencil and paint on paper is nieche online, so you can imagine my opinion on ai art
1742779698858.jpeg


for disposable yt thumbnails it's fine
 
Now that this has Commes des Fuckdown a bit, I'll give my take.

I think we're too late to put the genie back in the bottle. For-profit public traded corporations will never not seek the cheapest way to exclude or devalue human resources. This is the nature of the profit model. They will use AI regardless of the drawbacks so long as it's cheaper than human labor and does good enough (which is the level of value they have for their products).

So we are stuck working towards figuring out how to proceed with this technology as part of life. For one, we need more sustainable energy sources, as AI uses an insane amount of it and needs to be kept from destroying the world. And we'll need regulations in place to stop it from taking more energy than it should reasonably use. These will not be easy things to achieve.

Furthermore, there's the economic problem. Ideally, art should not need to be financed, but realistically, it does. AI could be used as a supplement to artists for now, but we know it'll become a replacement in the long run. And that's not just for artists; ultimately, at least 90% of labor could be replaced with AI and/or robots. So we'll need to start off with regulations to keep the economy from collapsing, and then later on we'll need a whole new economic model.

As I said before Fully Automated Luxury Communism is the best new model proposed so far for the long run. There's also Universal Basic Income, which could be a part of FALC, but it is possible for malicious actors to abuse it to harm the public. (Note that a lot of malicious m/billionaires have claimed to support it, including some who want it to replace all social services. This would be a disaster.) Aside from those, no other plan has been suggested, but it's agreed by economists (left and right) that if nothing is done to change the economy, we could face economic collapse.

As for its value in art, that is subjective. Many AI works could be fixed up with Photoshop, GIMP, or other tools. Like I said, it's possible for it to be used by artists themselves. And while there's plenty of it that's bad, it's getting better over time, and it's not always bad for everything. (Certain anime-centered websites actually have better artwork from the AI artists now than from the hand-drawing artists.) And honestly, the R34 stuff is probably creating more jobs than taking them, so at least that part of the creative industry will do fine. (It's weird how the sex industry has been the only big independent growth industry in the last decade or so.) But hopefully we'll get past the technological inept gerontocracy soon enough to avoid turning ourselves into a bunch of sex workers.
 
I feel like a big part of the issue is that people just parrot what they hear online without actually educating themselves. They see Gen AI and go 'HISSSSSS BADDDD' without actually knowing what it is and what it's capable of.

I disagree with it being used to replace humans. I don't disagree with its existence.
 
I know artists hate to hear it, but people care about the result, not the process. I love when a movie is shot on film it looks better and requires a lot more skill but I also know that most people don't care. Digital cameras and film simulations have improved so much that it's financially irresponsible to shoot a movie on film. That’s not to say it should never be done, but it’s unreasonable to expect everyone to switch back.

Like digital cameras, AI has made many tasks that were once difficult and time-consuming trivial. I believe AI is best used as a tool to aid artists, not replace them.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
A plague that screws over artists and invades Google Image results.
 
I think of AI as another means to help get art or whatever hobby it is to the wider masses, it won't replace anyone or thing. I dont know how to say it, it's similar to when people were afraid that photography will make painting obsolete to which isn't true and that the two of these become it's very own niche and has its own following
IMG_4053.jpeg


OP wasn't wrong with that AI art is a plague that it's everywhere noew
It's something that's bound to happen one way or the other as technology advances
IMG_4052.webp

And this is clearly much more appealing both the average non-art savvy individuals and businesses to go for since it's much cheaper for to go to an AI site somewhere and have an AI generate a bunch of art for you without losing a dime to entitled "artists" that either takes forever to finish a commission when they have too much on their hand already or they overcharge and grandstand to you, and the downside of using AI is in the name. it's artificial, won't be as good or have the details as a piece done by actual talented artists but it'll do the job
this ratlobber tweet summarise it best
IMG_4054.jpeg
 
Oh hey this dull thread is still up.

I don't know, I feel like AI was inevitable, it really makes me want to say aI told you so!

You could see it as an AI-volution! An AIye for an eye! It’s AImazingg! AI-scream for the future!

I got all day folks.
 
it makes searching for good hentai even more annoying. i said it!

But other than that, i think it really looks ugly in many cases, and the use of AI in General have not been soo great or smooth like people tell you all the time. Is like coding or writing. The amounts of times i have to discuss with my sister because she believed some bullshit the AI told her had really worsened our already fragile relationship and the same is happening with my Friends.

To be honest i really want to go back in time when all this shit didn't exist.
 
Well is it art or not ?is something I really don't care about ,but I like how it can make some of my visions come true even tho I'm not good at drawing
 
AI Art is good for using it as a reference tool for drawing something. Other than that, any use of AI art is cruel and everyone should stick to using references of other people's art, such as the art featured in video games, media, or even your friends'.
 
One argument that pro gen-AI people like to bring up is that it decentralizes art. I do not think this is true. Art was already decentralized but now big companies are feeding all the art (with or without consent) into a big database that trains their AI. To me that sounds like the opposite of decentralized.

Also one big thing about AI art is large corporations control what you can and can not create. I was messing around with an AI music editor for laughs but specific words will trigger an error message. Do you really want your creativity or game to be limited by the whims of big corporations or by the limits of the software?
 
One argument that pro gen-AI people like to bring up is that it decentralizes art. I do not think this is true. Art was already decentralized but now big companies are feeding all the art (with or without consent) into a big database that trains their AI. To me that sounds like the opposite of decentralized.

Also one big thing about AI art is large corporations control what you can and can not create. I was messing around with an AI music editor for laughs but specific words will trigger an error message. Do you really want your creativity or game to be limited by the whims of big corporations or by the limits of the software?
You can always generate locally with freeware/shareware builds. That will always be an option, with the only limitations being your knowledge on how it works/how to run it.

There is a massive issue on the corpo side in centralizing all media, though. That's a vary valid issue. Again, the issue comes from bigwigs improperly using the tool.
 
Lots of ethical issues when it comes to copyright and artists' works being used without their knowledge for training. As an artist, I personally don't get why anyone would take the fun part out of art by removing the process entirely. When companies use it, I immediately assume the product they're trying to sell me isn't worth it if they couldn't even bother to do marketing properly.

Personally, I don't think it will last long. There may be an AI boom in a lot of professional fields, but it's just a novelty that'll go nowhere, much like NFTs and any cryptocurrency after bitcoin. Big projects with people who care about the end result behind them will be hiring professionals instead of writing 40 prompts to an AI in hopes it'll turn out something useable, and AI will eventually become synonymous with low quality in the eyes of the wider public, companies will jump out of the AI ship and hire artists again. As soon as the regulations around AI get tighter, it'll die quickly.

That, or there will be so much AI art on the internet that the models will start being trained on it and the quality will decrease so much no one wants to use it anymore.
Post automatically merged:

That's actually a very interesting point. To you, what makes a Vocaloid song different from an AI-generated song? You're still feeding a real person's input (in this case, a real singer's voice) into a piece of software, then using it to generate a track that isn't sung by a human and that the original artist doesn't have ownership over. Couldn't you say it's essentially the same thing as, like, Suno or something, just with slightly more direct input by a producer?
Additional difference, the people providing the voices for the Vocaloids are under a contract and get paid their fair share, they know their voices are going to be used. With AI voices, the people don't know their voices are being used, they're not getting paid anything, and they never signed up for it. For singers (and voice actors too) it's taking away their jobs in a much more targeted way than other AI generated products
 
Last edited:
AI upscale (for touch ups and movies like what they do for Spiderverse or when Atlus tried to make P3P a little better)= fine
Generative AI (the one that's actually theft)= bad

It's important not to conflate the two, yet some people have
That's my take. Gen AI still looks like shit though, I can't believe there are people who look at that mess and go "I made this."
 
hqdefault.jpg

FIX THE EXTRA HANDS AND FINGERS FFS IT'S WEIRD
 
What do you think about it?

I'll start:

In my honest opinion, I think its kind of like a "plague", can't look anywhere without seeing it...
Recently, shops in my area started using it. Why can't they get a picture off the internet, or, hire an artist? Its totally BS in my opinion.
For some reason ai art can be so good or so bad. I think even if ai make a great art, it's better to use artist. No matter how it's good air always add some weird mistake on it which freak me out.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Connect with us

Support this Site

RGT relies on you to stay afloat. Help covering the site costs and get some pretty Level 7 perks too.

Latest Threads

Cyberpunk game suggestions?

I only have two criteria:
Must be from Snes to Dreamcast + DS and PSP(that's what my handheld...
Read more

Music that is hard to place in any category or music style

Hey people, please share some cool music that is hard to place in any category or music style...
Read more

What game or genre relaxes you the most while playing?

Fairly sure there was a topic like this one already, but couldn't find it.

Anyway... What sort...
Read more

Who has played switch 2 your thoughts on it

How's Nintendo switch 2 for those who own it or played it?
Read more

I never got why

people in prison dont live that long. I mean even when its not due to violence its like people...
Read more

The F-Zero Thread

I’m sad, but not surprised that a thread hasn’t been made for this series, so here we go…
YOU...
Read more

How many chapters for a series/stories should have?

What is the best amount of chapters, a series should have.
From Beginning to End

Is it's 12...
Read more

Online statistics

Members online
171
Guests online
194
Total visitors
365

Forum statistics

Threads
9,844
Messages
243,499
Members
777,492
Latest member
Akira10

Advertisers

Back
Top