I preferred Alan Wake to Alan Wake 2. While Alan Wake 2 can be visually spectacular, I preferred the storytelling, the characters, and the gameplay of the first. While there were probably too many repetitive shootouts in the first with The Taken, I found the sequel to have far too little of it. There was a whole lot walking and a lot less action. Whereas I've replayed the first game many times, I've only played Alan Wake 2 twice and I can't see myself playing it much more than that. By comparison, I've replayed Max Payne 1/2, Alan Wake 1+DLC, Quantum Break and Control many times. I've only played American Nightmare a few times, though.
I agree with Wanted: Dead and Slitterhead. Those are two of my more recent favorite weirdo games. By the way, while I'm talking about Wanted: Dead, you reminded me of another "bad game" that I love:
View attachment 22142