Alas, t'was not to be...but what can I say? I like me some mascot platformers. :P
I've never played any of the other games nominated (well, except SMT 3, but I've never beaten it) so I get to experience something new no matter what else wins. ^^
I never played the Sheep Dog one but I used to have a gaming mag with a full page ad in it for that game and it always looked like fun.
I recently went back and played Bugs Bunny: Lost in Time, the game that preceded Time Busters, and I proper enjoyed it. It's cool seeing how Time Busters improved on the formula with different styles of gameplay and puzzles.
I might re-visit one of the Looney Tunes games for Gameboy Colour, there were some good'ns on there too.