Another honorable mention, to me, is the XBox One.
Is it overtly awful? No…
Does it have games? Yes, in the technical sense.
View attachment 69453
But it’s boring. Like… really REALLY boring. And offensive at the beginning of its life. This console pissed everybody off in 2013 with a slew of features that they would later have to pull back on. This whole system was initially designed around everything nobody wanted from XBox, and even after all those things were taken out of it… nobody cared. This system is the most boring, boxy, loser I’ve ever seen.
The Hyperscan is notable. It’s too wild to forget.
The weird motion control add-ons you all throw out are too wild to forget.
Notoriety matters. It matters for something.
So, ask yourself, what happens when you get a console with no personality, no exclusives that people care about, and no real hook to ownership over the course of its lifetime? You get the XBox One. A system that even people who owned one as kids… don’t care about. A complete failure. Sure, it sold units, but what else did it even do? Name one notable thing it has that would make me care. Outside of Rare Replay, I can’t think of anything.
The PS4… is a total reset to your gaming library. No backwards compatibility, just starting from scratch. Its’ early exclusives, and up until around 2015 exclusives, are some of the lowest tier of PlayStation you could ever get. The controller is a flimsy experiment that not many people liked and mostly just tolerated while the light bar put a glare on their screen during play. The system is bogged down with PlayStation Eye, a useless peripheral that no games supported and had no clear way for games to support anyway (really, what games would YOU design for that godforsaken thing?) and the system’s early library was full of selling you slightly up-rezzed ports of PS3 games, a sales success that would lead us directly into the glut of ports and no-effort full price remasters we see today.
And yet the PS4 was beloved.
How hard do you have to make a console the worst and most feckless option… to make the PS4 IN ITS EARLY LIFE an actual success in the eyes of people?
The XBox One. I know multiple people who own one. It’s my go to example for how sales don’t matter for NOTHING in the gaming world. This thing sold. But it sold to the people who were never going to buy a PS4 anyway. It sold to all the people who mindlessly consume games or don’t have the time to consider game purchases anymore because they have kids. And I can tell you, for every family I know who had one, not a single one of the people I know played on their XBox One almost EVER. There was no emotional attachment. No love. No care. Just a boring, black box that might as well be a void where all the most boring elements of gaming come from. You want to know why XBox is where it is today? You want to know why it’s so hard to get people to care about the weird, wonderful, and interesting stuff from old XBox? This is why.
This system is the reason why nobody cares about XBox… except to clown on them and tell them to just go away already. It’s pathetic that Microsoft, with all their billions, never even TRIED to salvage this console with a big and interesting game. Because why would they? They’re Microsoft. Selling to the boring mass market is all they know. And the people that made XBox anything more than that were long gone from the brand by the time the One sauntered into stores.