Hot takes

[God-Shattering Twink]

Sonic P-06 is at least decent for most people around. In fact this is the only way people should experience it (unless they really, really want to have the "authentic" feeling but I don't really think this would be worth it).

No, on the other hand I wouldn't use that game to claim that the original was good, it's like saying Simon's Quest is the best NES Castlevania just because there's a patch fixing the game's flaws.

I would say at least 3 really bad games (Boom included even if it's not canonical I'll still add to the series) and Lost World + Forces while not being good are nowhere near as tedious as Shadow nor 2006, just extremely bland games that tried to be too safe (and the opposite of the spectrum of those two).

As said above it'd be like taking Mario is Missing (yes, even if it's not developed by Nintendo EAD), Bomberman Act:Zero and even Metroid Other M then claim all of these franchises aren't good and anybody actually claiming they are would just be doing "revisionist mental gymnastic" which is a bit too easy to deflect any counterargument...

As an Adventure fan, P06 is frustratingly good, it really makes me wish the original 06 wasn't a such a trainwreck. However I will always encourage people to play the most faithful versions of games with popular patches/fixes, just to get an idea of why they're so infamous. Recently i've seen a large uptick in people calling 06 "misunderstood" after playing P06, because they don't have the context of how awful the original game was.

 

[KaiserMk7]

No, on the other hand I wouldn't use that game to claim that the original was good, it's like saying Simon's Quest is the best NES Castlevania just because there's a patch fixing the game's flaws.

Which Simon's Quest fan remake is the best though?

 

[Pandaprewmaster325]

Sheesh you guys write too much , on waffle comment about fan patches yea they are cool but the thing is they aren't "official" that will always be an obstacle because you can't get these cool stuff when you first install the game you have to look for it.

 

[MasterEn]

Sheesh you guys write too much , on waffle comment about fan patches yea they are cool but the thing is they aren't "official" that will always be an obstacle because you can't get these cool stuff when you first install the game you have to look for it.

if we want to write a post with enough words to rival the page count of ace attorney justice for all [1500 pages], then we will. and you can't stop us.

 

[Pandaprewmaster325]

if we want to write a post with enough words to rival the page count of ace attorney justice for all [1500 pages], then we will. and you can't stop us.

That would be too much lol , how about this hotcake , video game dialouge should consist of a round 20 words at most

 

[MasterEn]

That would be too much lol , how about this hotcake , video game dialouge should consist of a round 20 words at most

 

[Samatonic Samatonic]

The more we are gaining, the less time we have for them.