while i agree that cid and vincent not being playable until part 3 of the remakes is disappointing, i feel their exclusions do not cause the game to be a worse finished product as a whole
the exploration in rebirth is fantastic, with worthwhile secrets hidden everywhere, lots of difficult, optional combat encounters that unlock more and more materia, the materia system itself being far more deep than in remake part 1, each party member playing so differently - the experimentation in rebirth is off the charts in a very pleasant way to me
linearity and hand-holding has been toned down greatly, the revamped combat is much improved, the spirit of the original game's minigame obsession is represented strongly, the triple-triad style card game they added is a lot of fun, all the little unique character interactions in both the main quests and side quests - it really does feel like square let themselves make a game with a more unabashed silliness to it
i am more than fine with cid and vincent not being playable in rebirth when the rest of the game is this far improved - compared to rebirth, remake part 1 is absolutely an anaemic and weak release