Raccoon City or Silent Hill

[Elwiwi]

Another one sent to the gonner hell

I have never played Silent Hill, plus I've seen a bunch of the "adult" Nexus mods
for Jill Valentine... I'm going with Racoon City.

View attachment 137064

View attachment 137065

 

[Retro Doomer]

I have never played Silent Hill, plus I've seen a bunch of the "adult" Nexus mods
for Jill Valentine... I'm going with Racoon City.

View attachment 137064

View attachment 137065

Please Delete the first picture its not SFW and NSFW is not allowed on this forum.
Good it seems to be gone now.

 

[Badseed Badseed]

Another one sent to the gonner hell

Gooner? Is that why my palms are hairy.

Please Delete the first picture its not SFW and NSFW is not allowed on this forum

OK. I'll try something different...
I will go to Racoon City to meet Barry and hear all his great lines like:
"You were almost a Jill Sandwich", "It Might Be Handy If You, The Master Of Unlocking, Take It With You" and the good old "It's A Weapon, It's Really Powerful, Especially Against Living Things".

As for survival, AVGN did It, why can't I?

 

[Retro Doomer]

OK. I'll try something different...
I will go to Racoon City to meet Barry and hear all his great lines like:
"You were almost a Jill Sandwich", "It Might Be Handy If You, The Master Of Unlocking, Take It With You" and the good old "It's A Weapon, It's Really Powerful, Especially Against Living Things".

View attachment 137077

As for survival, AVGN did It, why can't I?
View attachment 137079

Well I am not the rule maker but I am the enforcer

nah its just better to avoid troubling the mods they have to deal with enough BS here.
The Voice acting of the first game truly was em ...well unique ;)

 

[Pandaprewmaster325]

I played silent hill 1 , and honestly i would feel more safe in the cafe than anywhere in racoon city.

Both choices are bad , but getting into the mini market in SH1 it's chill and there is a lot of supplies there.

An interesting thing one time i went to my uncle's house and it was night and they have a garden at that point i think i heard a dog and my thoughts went immediately to RE1 garden i felt a little of discomfort and unsafe as i thought "great looks like a place for some cerberus dogs" i felt the physical threat at that moment XD , yeah my mind is my greatest enemy so i guess SH would be a bad choice? But if we are talking IRL it also means more realistic movement so you duck under cars or peek through doors instead of opening the door ENTERING THE ROOM THEN FINDING OUT A MONSTER IS SITTING IN THE CORNER , you can't just take pills or whatever if you get hit too...

MOST people here are civilians so our handling of firearms will be different , our usage and skills will vary.

But how do you get into silent hill to begin with? The town needs to be interested in you one way or another to get you teleported otherwise you just gonna go to a tourist filled town.

AND if that's what happens with me ey I'm happy.

 

[Retro Doomer]

MOST people here are civilians

Meanwhile me:

And I understand ya pal depending on certain factors Silent Hill could be safer or be more dangerous.
The Silent Hill 1 version of the town would be easier especially if we consider the enemy count which is far lower at least it was for me which makes the easier to avoid and besides we are not the Protagonists so we would not be forced to fight the bosses.

Also I am sure most humans have done shit we regret in our life and this is probably what Silent Hill would feed upon to lure us in I guess if we need a reason ;).

 

[Pandaprewmaster325]

Meanwhile me:

And I understand ya pal depending on certain factors Silent Hill could be safer or be more dangerous.
The Silent Hill 1 version of the town would be easier especially if we consider the enemy count which is far lower at least it was for me which makes the easier to avoid and besides we are not the Protagonists so we would not be forced to fight the bosses.

Also I am sure most humans have done shit we regret in our life and this is probably what Silent Hill would feed upon to lure us in I guess if we need a reason ;).

If you idle outside in SH1 a flying creature will come and attack you , so i assume same rule here applies.

We would be replacement of the protagonist......so i guess we still have to face the bosses.

Though if we talking about SH1 version that means alissa is alive and OH GOD those rompers exist...

 

[Retro Doomer]

Don

If you idle outside in SH1 a flying creature will come and attack you , so i assume same rule here applies.

We would be replacement of the protagonist......so i guess we still have to face the bosses.

Though if we talking about SH1 version that means alissa is alive and OH GOD those rompers exist...

Don't worry the Protagonists still exist which does not mean we meet them though.
But at least we would not have worry about the bosses.
And good thing I was constantly walking then unless in a safe Zone.
I alos hated those flying thing and those ape fucks in the calanisation.

 

[Adachi_08]

Racoon City. Definetly.

Considering my current mental health silent hill would be a torture. But Racoon City? I mean yeah, zombies, lickers, all that stuff, but all of that stuff is guaranteed to be in the city. Yeah i can perish and become a zombie, but i think it would be better than being tortured and haunted by the demons that are specifically made based on my mental problems and guilts.

And point about Tyrant/Nemesis. If i remember correctly the only troublesome one would Tyrant cuz he was airdroppped to the police station and he was mostly there for the whole game. And Nemesis was specifically made to hunt down S.T.A.R.S. memebrs, so as long as i stay away from the main cast amd avoid police station i should be somewhat fine.

Also Claire Redfield would be there so....

Also it seems Redfield bloodline will live on after all

 

[jankusanagi jankusanagi]

View attachment 137039

I'm gonna die anyway, and in Raccoon City I can meet Claire and Jill, so...

 

[ThatOneLum ThatOneLum]

I have never played Silent Hill, plus I've seen a bunch of the "adult" Nexus mods
for Jill Valentine... I'm going with Racoon City.



View attachment 137065

Wait, can we NexusMod our versions of the cities?

That might change some stuff.

 

[Badseed Badseed]

Wait, can we NexusMod our versions of the cities?

That might change some stuff.

Nobody said we couldn't

 

[Retro Doomer]

Nobody said we couldn't

View attachment 137107

It would defeat the purpose of the question though otherwise you could just mod it into our own dream.

Racoon City. Definetly.

Considering my current mental health silent hill would be a torture. But Racoon City? I mean yeah, zombies, lickers, all that stuff, but all of that stuff is guaranteed to be in the city. Yeah i can perish and become a zombie, but i think it would be better than being tortured and haunted by the demons that are specifically made based on my mental problems and guilts.

And point about Tyrant/Nemesis. If i remember correctly the only troublesome one would Tyrant cuz he was airdroppped to the police station and he was mostly there for the whole game. And Nemesis was specifically made to hunt down S.T.A.R.S. memebrs, so as long as i stay away from the main cast amd avoid police station i should be somewhat fine.



Also it seems Redfield bloodline will live on after all

Oh certainly but not trough Chris Redfield as Jill is just a "friend" of course to him and you would not date a friend..I seen the memes and they are funny.

 

[petran79]

Silent Hill. Talismans are easier to use than guns

 

[Pandaprewmaster325]

Don

Don't worry the Protagonists still exist which does not mean we meet them though.
But at least we would not have worry about the bosses.
And good thing I was constantly walking then unless in a safe Zone.
I alos hated those flying thing and those ape fucks in the calanisation.

Well there a chance you meet them but the town had decides really , also i think if you go into silent hill the town won't kill you but it wants something from you.

Yeah flyers are tough but rompers are tougher and can't melee them AT ALL

 

[TheMinuMaster]

For me, Silent Hill would be more fun and easier, and I’d probably have a smoother experience, like in the first game.

 

[ThunderBoy]

Raccoon City for me

 

[redux007]

Eh, both are guaranteed death. SH1 has a cadre of demons that put anything aside from SH2's pyramid to shame in terms of lethality. The Raccoon City incident saw the death of Special Forces, SWAT, and other paramilitary forces. Even super human monsters like Wesker and Nemesis didn't stay in a single spot for too long. The city's hordes are death, the lickers are death, the dogs are death, plus a thousand other mutants/monsters, and if you manage to "evacuate" you'll most likely get caught in the nuke and die from the fallout or get gunned down by Umbrella or US Military personal enforcing the quarantine. I suppose I would go with Raccoon City because at least I'd be in the same dimension as the Earth and could at least hypothetically leave.

 

[ThatOneLum ThatOneLum]

Eh, both are guaranteed death. SH1 has a cadre of demons that put anything aside from SH2's pyramid to shame in terms of lethality. The Raccoon City incident saw the death of Special Forces, SWAT, and other paramilitary forces. Even super human monsters like Wesker and Nemesis didn't stay in a single spot for too long. The city's hordes are death, the lickers are death, the dogs are death, plus a thousand other mutants/monsters, and if you manage to "evacuate" you'll most likely get caught in the nuke and die from the fallout or get gunned down by Umbrella or US Military personal enforcing the quarantine. I suppose I would go with Raccoon City because at least I'd be in the same dimension as the Earth and could at least hypothetically leave.

I dunno if I'd say SH is a guaranteed death.

If you can accept your own physoclogical shortcomings then you get to leave again, and the "monsters" are only as lethal as you make them. Several people walking around SH don't even necessarily see them as a threat, so it must be possible to co-exist with them.

Plus, in fairness, it only really matters if the town latches onto your psyche specifically. Arguably, we've seen times when NPCs have been in a town where the monsters are entirely based on the protagonist, so it's possible that when we get to SH it won't even be latched onto our demons, and we might have quite an easy time surviving. I mean hell, if Eddie can survive, why not us lmao.

 

[redux007]

I dunno if I'd say SH is a guaranteed death.

If you can accept your own physoclogical shortcomings then you get to leave again, and the "monsters" are only as lethal as you make them. Several people walking around SH don't even necessarily see them as a threat, so it must be possible to co-exist with them.

Plus, in fairness, it only really matters if the town latches onto your psyche specifically. Arguably, we've seen times when NPCs have been in a town where the monsters are entirely based on the protagonist, so it's possible that when we get to SH it won't even be latched onto our demons, and we might have quite an easy time surviving. I mean hell, if Eddie can survive, why not us lmao.

I think that defeats the point of the exercise, doh. Plus I'm imagining SH1, which is a third party's nightmares. Not the MC's.

 

[ThatOneLum ThatOneLum]

I think that defeats the point of the exercise, doh. Plus I'm imagining SH1, which is a third party's nightmares. Not the MC's.

A fair point, well-made, lmao.

Didn't even consider Harry's adventure tbh! Whenever I think of the series I tend to mentally start on 2 which is a bit silly tbh. As much as I love that game it also gave us pyramid head who become the most over-used monster in SH canon -.-

RE: SH1 though, it could be argued that the reason the town is so hostile to Harry is that beign attached to his "daughter" he would be aggressive against the monsters spawned from her psyche who are trying to harm her. Then again, Cybil has 0 connection to Alyssa outside of having a vague history with another child being bought into town and murdered or w/e, but she still gets attacked/possessed.

I think the reason this topic is so interesting is cus there's so much nuance to it.