If you could choose... what would you prefer? FF PSX era question inside.

[X y b e r - S k u ll]

While I normally have a stance against remakes, if I had to choose between these 2, I'd pick VIII. IX I think is perfect as is (Although a re-translation of the game would be welcome seeing as A LOT was lost in the localisation of that game), and VIII was always dog shit to me so maybe they could try and make it an actual good game with a remake (Which I guess is the ideal mindset for remakes in my mind; take bad things and try and make them good).

 

[gokusmacksmyds]

I can't be bothered to read the thread and I assume this point has already been made but:

FFIX is pretty much perfect as is, it really doesn't need a remake.

FFVIII is a functional game that tried something new but has a broken combat system that needs a entire overhaul to make it fun.