Games that deserve a re-do or a remake

[hulpmiddles]

What are games that should be redone (games that are not good but if they fix it it could be good) or games that deserve a remake.

For me, Sonic 06 should be redone if they fix the glitches and does quality of life improvements it could become a amazing game on part with sonic adventure. I like Sonic 06 but i cant deny the game is flawed.

Mega Man Legends/Mega Man 64 should also be re-done i think that game has great potential it just needed to be fleshed out more and more action packed and also need quality of life improvements

Frogger: The Great Adventure Also needs re-done it has potential yet the pacing is slow and some levels drag long and gets boring fast.

Remake wise, The Sonic Adventure games are dying for a remake the games are amazing yet are trapped due to outdated ways on how they handled 3D games then.

 

[Tonberry]

While I'm usually biased against the idea of remakes, I tend to prefer them when they play it straight, instead of adding all kinds of crazy additions.

That being said, I've fantasized about a remake of 'The Simpsons Hit & Run' where all the worlds were interconnected and with cool toon-shaded graphics that could emulate the look of the show.

Also the 6th gen Hobbit game. Love that game to death, but I'd love it even more if it was accessible on modern hardware with crisp graphics.

 

[CheelaCheela's icon]

CASTLEVANIA JUDGEMENT! Castlevania as a series has crazy potential to get a good fighting game, why did they drop the ball soo hard

 

[Elwiwi]

Xenogears and Xenosaga I~III and also golden sun would be cool

 

[bjork]

Gun.Smoke. How Capcom initially funded Red Dead Revolver, then handed it over to Rockstar at some point, watched Red Dead become huge (which didn't happen until Redemption, mind you) and never once went, "man, we got another cowboy game too, what if we did something with that" still blows my mind.

I also want a rerelease of the first PSO, I don't even need the visuals updated or anything. I would probably prefer if they weren't. All I ask for is right stick camera control.

 

[LiberoVulpesLiberoVulpes's icon]

Homeworld Cataclysm deserves the remaster treatment the other games had, its such a shame that the source code was lost and Gearbox doesn't want to recreate it, hell it took ages to get Gearbox to accept Cataclysm as canon.

 

[UnDubious]

A decent remake of Before Crisis, the lost FFVII mobile game that never got an English release, would be cool. There's a fan remake but it was made by one amateur guy in rpgmaker and it shows, the battles especially look a lot worse than in the original. This is pre-gacha games and all this trash.

 

[jankusanagi]

Xenogears and Xenosaga I~III and also golden sun would be cool

Xenogears +1000!!

Also, Chrono Cross could use a beautiful, but *faithful* remake.
Dino Crisis, Parasite Eve...

Final Fantasy V and VI could really use nice remakes too. I'd be happy with something like the FFIII remake for the PSP, nothing too fancy

 

[Captain Murphy]

VAGRANT STORY

 

[Bakuma1997]

The first Mother, the Begginings (Rimshot) of the saga deserves to be refreshed and modernized, i know about Encore, but knowing Them, i am waiting for the cancellation news T-T

 

[Strategist's iconStrategist]

It would have to be an unfinished game or a game that was severely limited by technical issues or bugs for me to get behind a remake project. Someone mentioned Xenogears, that sounds like a perfect project for a remake if they can complete disk 2 in their full vision.

The problem with remakes is that the experience is ultimately changed in ways that make it fundamentally different. At that point, it isn't reflective of the original game, so what's the point of retreading an old story that's slightly altered and edited for modern sensibilities?

 

[Dyne]

Yup, Xenogears 1000%

 

[tigg]

My biggest wish would be Legend of Dragoon

 

[Samatonic]

 

[ATenderLad]

It would have to be an unfinished game or a game that was severely limited by technical issues or bugs for me to get behind a remake project. Someone mentioned Xenogears, that sounds like a perfect project for a remake if they can complete disk 2 in their full vision.

The problem with remakes is that the experience is ultimately changed in ways that make it fundamentally different. At that point, it isn't reflective of the original game, so what's the point of retreading an old story that's slightly altered and edited for modern sensibilities?

This is gonna get playfully off-topic, but I'd kinda argue that Disc 2 is already basically complete? Experiencing the story in a more decompressed form would be better than just having a narrator tell us what happened, of course, but I think less would be more here. Part of the reason the game feels unfinished is because people new to managing a project couldn't edit Xenogears down to what mattered. I'm not saying I know exactly what that should be, but I'm tempted to say all of the bits and pieces of different time periods should have just been hints and veiled references.

(Short version, I'd cut Esmeralda and that entire subplot, and shorten up Grahf and Krelians backstories a ton. Also, maybe just fucking lose Grahf entirely. I think ID already serves a lot of the same function in the story, and Grahf feels like a hat on a hat in terms of Fei's many, many secret origins. Like ohmygod this man has too many secret origins, he's like Wolverine).

 

[Stingy Perry]

Parasite Eve series nuff said.

 

[tigg]

Parasite Eve series nufft said.

the first PE is getting a remake, was announced not that long ago, but I do hope we get part 2 as well. Part 3 I can live without

 

[hulpmiddles]

the first PE is getting a remake, was announced not that long ago, but I do hope we get part 2 as well. Part 3 I can live without

Speaking of games that got a remake for the first game but not the second, Pac Man World 2 and Croc 2 needs remakes honestly probably more then the first games. But the removal of the tank controls for Croc 1 was a W.

 

[Strategist's iconStrategist]

This is gonna get playfully off-topic, but I'd kinda argue that Disc 2 is already basically complete? Experiencing the story in a more decompressed form would be better than just having a narrator tell us what happened, of course, but I think less would be more here. Part of the reason the game feels unfinished is because people new to managing a project couldn't edit Xenogears down to what mattered. I'm not saying I know exactly what that should be, but I'm tempted to say all of the bits and pieces of different time periods should have just been hints and veiled references.

(Short version, I'd cut Esmeralda and that entire subplot, and shorten up Grahf and Krelians backstories a ton. Also, maybe just fucking lose Grahf entirely. I think ID already serves a lot of the same function in the story, and Grahf feels like a hat on a hat in terms of Fei's many, many secret origins. Like ohmygod this man has too many secret origins, he's like Wolverine).

Those are all fair points and that brings me to another reason why I think remakes suck. The people who remake these games sometimes are disconnected to the original vision and get far too precious about them. I'm sure if modern day Square Enix tried to remake Xenogears, they'd just leave every superfluous scene and expand it to twice the length while also missing the overall thematic point of the story. I'm sure they would also leave all the annoying platforming sections because they have to be authentic to the original.

 

[hulpmiddles]

While I'm usually biased against the idea of remakes, I tend to prefer them when they play it straight, instead of adding all kinds of crazy additions.

Honestly I usually play the original games on the original hardware via a real machine or emulation. But i always like the options of remakes.

 

[ATenderLad]

I'm sure they would also leave all the annoying platforming sections because they have to be authentic to the original.

Okay but if the Tower of Babel section becomes "lol we have flying robots" and you just skip all that shit, I'll pay $80 right now.

 

[Pearly]

Xenogears and Xenosaga I~III and also golden sun would be cool

I would think xenogears for definite, fully completed and given the FF7 rebirth treatment. For xenosaga 2 that would need to be completely overhauled, xenosaga 1 could be retooled and reskinned and three just a graphical overhaul.

I think megaman X7 and X8 definitely need a re do, they suck

 

[hulpmiddles]

I think megaman X7 and X8 definitely need a re do, they suck

Honestly Mega Man X should have ended at 5 like the series creator Keiji Inafune intended it to be.

 

[OPT1MUS]

Primal was such a beautiful game (to me, at least). A great game from Studio Cambridge.
I think it also was quite underestimated, back in 2003.
It would deserve a remake (or maybe a good sequel)...

 

[rugal]

wild arms 2 it really deserves a remake its so good game
the game was so good the storie. all hidden things in the game and all optional bosse did make the game so fun to play
puzzles in the game was hard at times but fun to solve