Emulation vs. Original Hardware

I can think of only one reason to own a game console: Games that are impossible to dump and emulate. So buy a Genesis so you can play Paprium.

Okay, okay, there's a second reason: consoles that aren't sufficiently cycle-accurately emulated (Such as the N64) where homebrew and romhacks cannot use deep hardware tricks that work on the hardware, but break on all emulators. Kaze Emmanuar has a running list of such optimizations, but he actively avoids using them because only the smallest fraction of the userbase actually plays them on hardware. Once Ares accurately emulates these hardware quirks, you have zero excuses to not ditch your console for good.

For everything else, remember that cartridges and CD's/DVD's are just antique low-capacity storage devices for ROMs. You can fit the entire contents of a "collector's" (read: Hoarder's) mid-life crisis Man Cave on a 24TB external Hard Drive. 1,000 ft^2 reduced to 3 1/2" x 5". heck, buy three drives so you have two backups, and you've only lost three more inches of vertical space in your house.

Game systems are now like the PICO-8: a series of hardware and software constraints you opt into in order to create art using limitations of a medium.

CRT Shaders, while not cycle-accurate to the devices they're intending to emulate, are good enough for most games, and it's only a matter of time before some sufficiently-autistic individual decides to dedicate himself to emulating these devices at a level where Bob from RetroRGB can no longer tell the difference. If you were a kid during the 2600-SNES Era, it's a guarantee you didn't play your system on an Aperture Grille professional Sony monitor; You played those games on a 10-15yo (at the time) Family TV that was plugged-in using the 75 Ohm RF input, if the TV was new enough to not just have 2 300 Ohm antenna screws. It was the only TV you had in the house, unless you were lucky to have a black & white 13" TV in your bedroom. If you had bad grounding in your house, you'd have to bend the video cable near the plug in just the right way in order to prevent ghosting on your TV or ensure a 10% more crisp picture. RCA Jacks? You mean those colored cables you plugged into your VCR before that VCR plugged into your RF port on your TV?
Compared to this, NTSC shaders are far better visually than the TV I used to beat half the NES catalog. It's downright adorable to watch kids born during the 4th and 5th generation of gaming complain about how bad CRT shaders look, because you're literally too young to know how truly accurate those shaders really are for most of us. If you yung'uns were honest, you'd admit that CRT Royale is better than every consumer television released during the Playstation/N64 Era, and it's not even close.

Input Lag, you say? Shut up and enable Run-Ahead and/or Preemptive Frames. I'm sure your Ryzen 5 7000-series system with a RTX 3070 will manage to keep up with such difficult and demanding hardware requirements in 2025.

So in closing, sell your man-caves while the market is peaking and convert to emulation. Spend your money on things that can't be emulated, such as gamepads and joysticks for the systems you like. Embrace gaming minimalism, so the things you own don't end up owning you.
 
Last edited:
It's all good.

I have multiple revisions of original hardware with flash carts and odes, old clones, modern SoC emulation based clones, the Analogue FPGA clones, a fully loaded MiSTer stack, a Steam Deck, and 8 computers in my house & garage that has easy access to emulation.

I picked up the new Atari 7800+, I am waiting for the Analogue 3D to ship. I might buy a Miyoo Mini plus.

I don't know what I prefer, other than good accuracy. Emulating PC Engine kind of sucks so I prefer using a Duo. I am not crazy enough to collect and run OG Neo Geo hardware while the the MiSTer easily handles all of that.

The only thing I am really sure of is that if Gaben shadow drops a new Steam game console on the market soon I will probably scream into a pillow until I pass out.

supernatural-jensen-ackles.gif
 
I personally enjoy using a Wii I got a year or two ago as an emulation machine, although I saw a snes for 60 bucks around here recently, I should check if it's still around when I get my next salary. Besides that, a PS3 for the PS1 emulation after plugging it into a CRT and my PS2, also on the CRT.

Personally anything pre-PS2 era feels like it requires a CRT, it just doesn't look good on the new screens, PS2 games can pass but still look better on old displays.
 
I prefer to emulate almost every console
But the Nintendo DS and Nintendo 3ds, the feeling of those consoles has never, in my opinion, been able to be replicated through emulation
 
I usually prefer original consoles. Setting up and booting them up just feels like part of the experience for me that is lost with emulation. The nintendo 64 is one of those consoles that only feels right with original hardware mostly due to the controller. No third party controller has come close to replicating the feel and sensitivity of an OG 64 analog stick.

I still emulate sometimes mostly for QOL features like save states and rewind. Lagoon on SNES for example is actually pretty fun with fast forward to accelerate healing.
 
If I could afford to buy hardware again I would absolutely prefer the OG over emulation. However, I'm a broke girly and I love how far emulation has come! I have a bluetooth version of every controller for most consoles that I regularly play to try and keep it as faithful to the OG hardware I can. 8Bitdo has a ton of great controllers and I'm on the lookout for an OG N64 controller so I can convert it to a wireless one.
 
As much as I wanted to play some games on the regular console, the path of emulation comes to save the day because I refuse to pay 300 and 400 euros for a PSX game.
 
If I could afford to buy hardware again I would absolutely prefer the OG over emulation. However, I'm a broke girly and I love how far emulation has come! I have a bluetooth version of every controller for most consoles that I regularly play to try and keep it as faithful to the OG hardware I can. 8Bitdo has a ton of great controllers and I'm on the lookout for an OG N64 controller so I can convert it to a wireless one.
I didn't know you could convert them to wireless, does it need a dongle or is it bluetooth?
 
I didn't know you could convert them to wireless, does it need a dongle or is it bluetooth?
8bitdo sells Bluetooth conversion kits for older controllers so you can keep using them on new machines. They actually have quite a few controller mods, including a gamecube one, and they work with switch as well as any bluetooth. They send you a board and everything to do it you just take the controller apart and swap the guts for the new one.
 
8bitdo sells Bluetooth conversion kits for older controllers so you can keep using them on new machines. They actually have quite a few controller mods, including a gamecube one, and they work with switch as well as any bluetooth. They send you a board and everything to do it you just take the controller apart and swap the guts for the new one.
I've heard of 8bitdo I just didn't know they sold conversion kits. Looks like I'll have to take this route with an N64 and GameCube controller, ideally I'd like two of each.
 
I like the sound the PS1 disc drive makes when it hits the CD. It's not even the same if you're running it on a PS2.
I think things like this are very important. Not for everyone, I guess, but still, very important. The same way paper books are important. Some people are fine with eBooks. Others, on the other hand, need this kind of thing to enhance their experience, to make it richer.

Personally, I'm on team hardware. Except lately, I've found myself using emulators when I'm tired and don't feel like connecting one of my systems to the right TV (because yes, CRTs are important too) and so on. Also, while doing that, I discovered that I actually prefer certain games on emulators.

Like grinding-oriented RPGs, for example. Some of those are way, way too slow and don't allow you to skip battle animations, meaning you'll have to see the exact same thing again and again, endlessly. Emulators allow you to speed things up, and honestly, I've found that makes things way more exciting for me.
As much as I wanted to play some games on the regular console, the path of emulation comes to save the day because I refuse to pay 300 and 400 euros for a PSX game.

I feel you. Some games can be painfully expensive. Even recent ones (remember that Godzilla game for PS4?). Then again, when it's about older hardware, there are many different solutions to run backups.
 
Depends on the hardware, let's not fool ourselves some older controllers don't feel as good as current alternativas. I still prefer emulation for it's vast catalogue, but I won't Deby that actually holding a consolé/handheld/controller has a special magic to it
 
I can think of only one reason to own a game console: Games that are impossible to dump and emulate. So buy a Genesis so you can play Paprium.

Okay, okay, there's a second reason: consoles that aren't sufficiently cycle-accurately emulated (Such as the N64) where homebrew and romhacks cannot use deep hardware tricks that work on the hardware, but break on all emulators. Kaze Emmanuar has a running list of such optimizations, but he actively avoids using them because only the smallest fraction of the userbase actually plays them on hardware. Once Ares accurately emulates these hardware quirks, you have zero excuses to not ditch your console for good.

For everything else, remember that cartridges and CD's/DVD's are just antique low-capacity storage devices for ROMs. You can fit the entire contents of a "collector's" (read: Hoarder's) mid-life crisis Man Cave on a 24TB external Hard Drive. 1,000 ft^2 reduced to 3 1/2" x 5". heck, buy three drives so you have two backups, and you've only lost three more inches of vertical space in your house.

Game systems are now like the PICO-8: a series of hardware and software constraints you opt into in order to create art using limitations of a medium.

CRT Shaders, while not cycle-accurate to the devices they're intending to emulate, are good enough for most games, and it's only a matter of time before some sufficiently-autistic individual decides to dedicate himself to emulating these devices at a level where Bob from RetroRGB can no longer tell the difference. If you were a kid during the 2600-SNES Era, it's a guarantee you didn't play your system on an Aperture Grille professional Sony monitor; You played those games on a 10-15yo (at the time) Family TV that was plugged-in using the 75 Ohm RF input, if the TV was new enough to not just have 2 300 Ohm antenna screws. It was the only TV you had in the house, unless you were lucky to have a black & white 13" TV in your bedroom. If you had bad grounding in your house, you'd have to bend the video cable near the plug in just the right way in order to prevent ghosting on your TV or ensure a 10% more crisp picture. RCA Jacks? You mean those colored cables you plugged into your VCR before that VCR plugged into your RF port on your TV?
Compared to this, NTSC shaders are far better visually than the TV I used to beat half the NES catalog. It's downright adorable to watch kids born during the 4th and 5th generation of gaming complain about how bad CRT shaders look, because you're literally too young to know how truly accurate those shaders really are for most of us. If you yung'uns were honest, you'd admit that CRT Royale is better than every consumer television released during the Playstation/N64 Era, and it's not even close.

Input Lag, you say? Shut up and enable Run-Ahead and/or Preemptive Frames. I'm sure your Ryzen 5 7000-series system with a RTX 3070 will manage to keep up with such difficult and demanding hardware requirements in 2025.

So in closing, sell your man-caves while the market is peaking and convert to emulation. Spend your money on things that can't be emulated, such as gamepads and joysticks for the systems you like. Embrace gaming minimalism, so the things you own don't end up owning you.
I wish I could frame this comment. Particularly the part about CRT shaders.
 
For me, it's a bit of sunk cost fallacy lol. If I was getting into gaming today, I wouldn't bother with retro consoles at all. They're much too pricey, the games even more so, and for many it's not trivial to play them on modern hardware. Not to mention that some emulators like Dolphin can now upscale the games to look better than you can ever get on original hardware.

Yet... I can't help myself. I already have a large collection, what's one more game, one more system...
 
For me, it's a bit of sunk cost fallacy lol. If I was getting into gaming today, I wouldn't bother with retro consoles at all
I actually think about "what if" stuff now and then. Wonder how the current gen sees gaming. I don't have kids, so... no real clue. But I can't help but keep wondering. I mean, there are kids who love old music and waste their money on things like vinyl records, right? So... I dunno. Brings me back to my thought about paper books.
 
i don't like to consume media outside of my computer, so emulation. besides, you can render games in widescreen and at a higher res.
 
I grew up with my dad's Game Boy and later invested in my own Game Boy Advance and Advance SP devices when I got older. I LOVE playing on the original hardware, but I never got around to modding my systems for a more convenient experience. Like I wanted to mod my GBA to have a backlit screen instead of using my SP, because the regular Advance is so much more comfortable in my hands. But since I haven't gotten to it, I instead switched to just emulating Game Boy on other portable handhelds I have. And as cool as it is, it's just not the same feeling. Whether it's an Android or Windows device, there are always extra steps to open my game up (unless I automate it somehow, but then again, that becomes an extra step in of itself). I just really like the experience of the original hardware being a literal plug-and-play experience.
 
I prefer to play on real hardware if possible but given that retroachievements currently has no way of knowing what i'm doing on an actual NES, DS or the like, I will probably be emulating far more often.
 
i love original hardware but its so much more convenient to just load up an emulator ya know? =w=

especially when you have a computer that can pretty much emulate everything >:3
what kind of computer do you have that can emulate anything?
 
emulation is great when you have a decent computer, a decent controller, and plenty of storage.
 
Honestly I don´t care if I play emulator or OG hardware as long as I can play the game. But when it comes to PS2,PS3 and PSP, 3ds and such then I prefer hardware because they emulation is not there yet.

Take PS3 there are about 103 games that basically lets you see the intro and that it´s. And about 989 games that either can't be finished, have serious glitches or have insufficient performance.

PS2 is better than PS3 emulation but still allot of games run better on a real PS2 than the emulation and also you can you start the game on a ps2 with out the need to fiddle with allot of settings.

3ds, PSP and vita suffer the same issue as the PS3 allot of games just don´t work or run badly or glitch as heck.

So I say emulation for anything below Gen 6 is fine but 6 and up well I rather 100% use hardware.
 
I like both, and everyone has accurately listed the pros and cons of each. I'm getting rid of the last of my physical collection mainly because most of it collects dust and I don't want to lug stacks of heavy boxes around anymore when I have to move. I am old and tired and it's time for my nap.
 
Some games are made with the hardware in mind.

Thanks to a wiimote + nunchuck and PC sensor bar I will get I could finally enjoy the motion focused Wii games via emulation.
 
Nowadays? Emulation.

I'm at the point in my life where I want to have fewer material possessions in my life. Not more. I never really got into game collecting like a lot of retrogamers did (mostly rented games when I was a kid). So I don't have a lot to hold on to as it is. I've basically been selling off my games and systems in the reverse order I acquired them (though I'll probably keep my modded 360 and PS3 as those are still harder to emulate).

In the long run, I'll probably end up selling off even my childhood systems as I'm not as sentimental about them as I used to be. If anything, I'm much less so as I kinda don't want to remember my childhood in hindsight. I didn't really enjoy it despite all the great games I played when I was a kid. Besides, the memories I made were with the games (software) and not the machines that played them (hardware). I much prefer a PS4 controller over the SNES one I grew up with.

Since I can use newer hardware to run older hardware (and/or newer hardware to run older hardware in the case of projects like the the Mister FPGA system), having the older games and systems creates a redundancy in what I own. Another example is how I don't have a Windows 98 SE PC despite growing up with it. I can pretty much play every game I want with Windows 10 (and eventually Linux/BSD as I don't want to switch over to Windows 11) via emulation and compatibility layers/virtualization.

Also, I'll probably downsize my living arrangements eventually. So having less stuff will make it less cluttered overall.

Finally though, I actually prefer emulation over hardware. I'm genuinely interested in following the development of emulators (and their communities) today over the development of hardware back in the day. I love the versatility, portability and scalability of emulators over the static state of retrogaming systems. But I also see the value of perfect accuracy and flashcarts/optical drive emulators with the old hardware too.

So whatever works for you... that's the best way to do it.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Connect with us

Support this Site

RGT relies on you to stay afloat. Help covering the site costs and get some pretty Level 7 perks too.

Latest Threads

Widescreen rendering in Ancient Roman - Power of Dark Side

When you turn widescreen rendering on in Duckstation while emulating Ancient Roman - Power of...
Read more

Thoughts on Crisis Core?

I'm about halfway through Crisis Core and I'm really enjoying it! Dare I say that the gameplay...
Read more

Losing your save

I was never a fan of JRPGs, but I decided to give it a try with Dragon Quest VII on my modded...
Read more

Hey, Let's talk about Sega Game Gear games

Until the release of the Gameboy Color the Sega Game Gear was the most powerful portable video...
Read more

The Perfect Place.

A "special place" you would like to be, maybe when you are sad, or feeling down, or in a bad...
Read more

Luigi's Mansion - Premium Deluxe

Started listening to Coldwave. Think it might be the most underrated musical genre. Any fans here?

Started getting into Coldwave and its a style that really speaks to me. Found some really damn...
Read more

Online statistics

Members online
145
Guests online
175
Total visitors
320

Forum statistics

Threads
9,912
Messages
245,525
Members
784,051
Latest member
sigmund_fryd

Advertisers

Back
Top