Earlier DOOM games are just "shoot to shoot" games, DOOM 3 game is "looking good but plays bad horror game", new reboot one is "fun" yet still empty. Later game is Super Mario Doom due to too much platforming and "I have no ammo to actually play this game" game lol, the newest one didn't add anything to the series whatsoever.
How Duke Nukem Forever is? The game is like testosterone over 9000 in funny meme way lol. It's fun to kill unlike any Doom game IMO, especially I like shotgun gameplay which this game is really a rare one that is actually fun, and there are fun rc car levels... In short be me and play games since arcade days and Atari 2600 era Duke Nukem Forever is a fun action game that offered good stuff.
Now people may get used to a new Call of Duty game and they may dislike it, or they may get used to playing a GTA game that you carry whole arsenal of tons of guns on you but you make dislike you can carry like 2 guns simultaneously, you may suck as racing games so you may dislike rc car driving levels. Yet I do think this game unfairly hated, especially when fake distortions to hate this game by feminist organisations and their brainwashes just to hate Duke Nukem to hate it. I do dislike the character, yet this character doesn't exist IRL, what I care about in an action game is naturally it's gameplay so it's fun IMO.
The original DOOM's are not solely focused on the shooting. Exploration, collecting items and puzzle solving are all in there too. The original DOOM trilogy are pretty universally beloved as some of the best games ever made.
DOOM 3 was a weak entry for me personally, but had extremely innovative graphics and lighting for the time. The atmosphere didn't quite work for me though.
Saying the new DOOM's have too much platforming is a YouTuber/video game critic take. If they took out the platforming, there'd be much less to separate one gunfight from the next. It was welcome variety in gameplay imo.
Duke Nukem Forever is incohesive. It was "ok" at best. The RC segment happens once or twice in the whole game for about 5 mins and then is never utilised again. It also just writes Duke like an asshole. In DUKE3D he's all about the ultra-macho "saving the chicks" thing, which is funny, but in Forever he's just kinda callous about their suffering. It's weirdly out of character, and not in a good way.
I don't hate Duke Nukem Forever, and if you love it, great. But to say it is better than every single DOOM game and that no DOOM game is better than a 7/10 is just unreal xD But yeah, agree to disagree.