Do you FPGA?

Waifu4Life

New Challenger
gem
Joined
Dec 1, 2024
Messages
18
Reaction score
29
Points
77
Location
Canada
While emulation is great for more powerful consoles from 6th gen and up, for me personally, games on: Famicom to N64, SG1000 to Saturn, PC-Engine/CD, PlayStation 1, NeoGeo AES/MVS, NeoGeo Pocket/Color and WonderSwan/Color are done on the MiSTer FPGA. I have a MiSTer MultiSystem on my CRT TV and a traditionnel stack in an aluminum case on my QLED TV.

Other FPGA systems do exists such as The Analogue Pocket for people who are into handhelds as well as Analogue's other FPGA systems. So, are you using FPGA?
 
I am on the Analogue Pocket and since beating Mike Tyson on Punch Out on it, I'll never go back to software emulation. Nothing against it and I thank it for all it's done the past 30 years, but I was never able to beat him on any software emulation solution I personally tried. Only original hardware on a CRT and now the Pocket.
 
I am on the Analogue Pocket and since beating Mike Tyson on Punch Out on it, I'll never go back to software emulation. Nothing against it and I thank it for all it's done the past 30 years, but I was never able to beat him on any software emulation solution I personally tried. Only original hardware on a CRT and now the Pocket.

While I am tempted to get an Analogue Pocket, I know it's not powerful enough to run 5th gen consoles. As we speak, heber.co.uk are working on their own DE10-Nano (the guts of the MiSTer Project) clone to include in their next version of the MultiSystem. This means that they could very well be on their way in making their own FPGA handheld.
 
Like otogirisou said, it's too expensive to justify for me, i could upgrade my pc for that price.
 
It's pretty cool but unless I had extra money to throw around I should focus on eventually getting a new laptop.

But these handhelds have always interested me.
 
If you were to purchase a DE10-Nano, sure, but the clones are much cheaper and work just as well (one of my MiSTers is a clone).
Got any suggestions then?
Last i looked a MiSTer multisystem costed over 500$, that's too much for me to justify.
 
Got any suggestions then?
Last i looked a MiSTer multisystem costed over 500$, that's too much for me to justify.
Absolutely *don't* put that kind of money in a scalper's pocket!!!

The *only* legit way to get a DE10 nano right now is from a reputible electronics supply house such as digikey or mouser. All you really need for MiSTer is the base board and a usb hub. An optional RAM module is highly recommended. (but those can be had for $50 and you can run many many many MiSTer cores without it!)



Intel jacked up the price a lot 2 years ago ($120 up to $230 or $240), and it is kind of a scam on their end. indie producers such as taki udon have proven that... the "mister pi" is $95 for the base board, and it is a slight upgrade from intel/alterra/terasic de10-nano.. but the sorry fomo situation is, that every time a batch is in stock, in sells out in minutes... then people turn around and sell them for double the money, anyway, it's pathetic.
...

i also highly recommend the Sipeed Tang nano 20k. It doesn't have nearly the cores, but for 40 dollar bundle, you can play nes, snes, gb out of the box, and Sipeed supports FPGA gaming (unlike intel)


^^this is the amazon link to get Sipeed tang nano 20k with gaming accessories for about $40.
also see nand2mario's github/blog for more information:

Small things retro

Post automatically merged:

also, intel has introduced now the new Agilex 3 line, which looks like it will be a replacement for the Cyclone V line (the features set is nearly identical, but with AI and PCI express 3 x4 support).. DE10 nano is probably nearing end of life unless intel changes it's attitude toward FPGA gamers.

 
Last edited:
Absolutely *don't* put that kind of money in a scalper's pocket!!!

The *only* legit way to get a DE10 nano right now is from a reputible electronics supply house such as digikey or mouser. All you really need for MiSTer is the base board and a usb hub. An optional RAM module is highly recommended. (but those can be had for $50 and you can run many many many MiSTer cores without it!)



Intel jacked up the price a lot 2 years ago ($120 up to $230 or $240), and it is kind of a scam on their end. indie producers such as taki udon have proven that... the "mister pi" is $95 for the base board, and it is a slight upgrade from intel/alterra/terasic de10-nano.. but the sorry fomo situation is, that every time a batch is in stock, in sells out in minutes... then people turn around and sell them for double the money, anyway, it's pathetic.
...

i also highly recommend the Sipeed Tang nano 20k. It doesn't have nearly the cores, but for 40 dollar bundle, you can play nes, snes, gb out of the box, and Sipeed supports FPGA gaming (unlike intel)


^^this is the amazon link to get Sipeed tang nano 20k with gaming accessories for about $40.
also see nand2mario's github/blog for more information:

Small things retro

Post automatically merged:

also, intel has introduced now the new Agilex 3 line, which looks like it will be a replacement for the Cyclone V line (the features set is nearly identical, but with AI and PCI express 3 x4 support).. DE10 nano is probably nearing end of life unless intel changes it's attitude toward FPGA gamers.

Thanks, i should be able to swing the price for the sipeed.
 
Thanks, i should be able to swing the price for the sipeed.
^^ yeah, i'm trying to get more people interested in it, because it's a pretty good platform. I should prolly stop being Tom Sawyer and start learning how to port cores over.

they also have a 60k pi hat model coming next month for $60-$70 (i think it still has it's own hdmi out too, so you can use it standalone). It will be able to run more stuff like megadrive and gba out of the box. (it should in theory be able to run ports of anything the analogue pocket can run).

There are also MSX, Amiga, and Atari ST cores out there, and i've seen Pac-man and tetris, but i haven't tried those yet.

The various cores for sipeed tang are kind of scattered all over github randomly. I'm not sure if there is a central hub or repository, but i've been collecting bookmarks for every project i can find.
 
@newageretrohippie
Yeah, scalpers are a pain, but I was able to get a MiSTer Pie easily in the 1st batch. Just make sure you account and shipping address are prepared and saved on the website is advance. The only issue I had with the entire thing is the fact that DHL sucks balls and can't keep up with their promised delivery hours if their lives depended on it.
 
@newageretrohippie
Yeah, scalpers are a pain, but I was able to get a MiSTer Pie easily in the 1st batch. Just make sure you account and shipping address are prepared and saved on the website is advance. The only issue I had with the entire thing is the fact that DHL sucks balls and can't keep up with their promised delivery hours if their lives depended on it.
yeah, taki is awesome... i had my info presaved, but there was a problem with verifying my card, and that was it.

Isn't it just crazy tho? he is able to independently produce a board that is practically identical to the DE10 nano, but can sell it for $95 instead of $230-240 which is evidently the new list price... and i'm assuming he was able to make a profit... he even hired a couple of folks to help him, i believe.

like, i know intel has had some financial issues in the past couple of years.. but this is ridiculous! It is 10 year old hardware, at this point. I had to RMA a DE10-nano due to a faulty hdmi port one time, and the first question they asked me was, "did you use it with MiSTer?"

They seriously hate the project. it's lame.
 
yeah, taki is awesome... i had my info presaved, but there was a problem with verifying my card, and that was it.

Isn't it just crazy tho? he is able to independently produce a board that is practically identical to the DE10 nano, but can sell it for $95 instead of $230-240 which is evidently the new list price... and i'm assuming he was able to make a profit... he even hired a couple of folks to help him, i believe.

like, i know intel has had some financial issues in the past couple of years.. but this is ridiculous! It is 10 year old hardware, at this point. I had to RMA a DE10-nano due to a faulty hdmi port one time, and the first question they asked me was, "did you use it with MiSTer?"

They seriously hate the project. it's lame.

The irony is that back in2019, I purchased for DE10-NANO for $97 CAD.
 
yeah, taki is awesome... i had my info presaved, but there was a problem with verifying my card, and that was it.

Isn't it just crazy tho? he is able to independently produce a board that is practically identical to the DE10 nano, but can sell it for $95 instead of $230-240 which is evidently the new list price... and i'm assuming he was able to make a profit... he even hired a couple of folks to help him, i believe.

like, i know intel has had some financial issues in the past couple of years.. but this is ridiculous! It is 10 year old hardware, at this point. I had to RMA a DE10-nano due to a faulty hdmi port one time, and the first question they asked me was, "did you use it with MiSTer?"

They seriously hate the project. it's lame.
It's one of the reasons why i distrust openly traded companies, they put profit above all else including sanity, the problem with this is profits are finite but investors want that number to go up forever.
 
It's one of the reasons why i distrust openly traded companies, they put profit above all else including sanity, the problem with this is profits are finite but investors want that number to go up forever.
Yeah, its weird for intel right now tho... to say they have had a bad couple of years is an understatement..

i think they just dont understand how the fpga market is changing.. it was a game they just bought into in the past decade...

traditionally, fpgas were used to:

a) teach logic design to college students (which was the purpose of de10 nano used in the mister)

b) specific industrial applications which require precise timing and tons of parallel i/o (things like digital signage or pro audio equipment), or

c) in the design of a vlsi/asic--so basically you design an asic for a very specific application at low clock speeds using an fpga, and then you "bake" the finshed design to the finished asic which can run at ghz speeds and be inexpensive to manufacture in bulk. (NES system-on-a-chip or bitcoin miners are well known examples)

...

but then tons of people started gaming directly on fpga sample boards over the past 5 years, and intel just hasnt embraced this new market at all...

if they lowered the price of the de10 nano to 100 dollars, they would sell 10s of thousands of units... they just dont get it


...

i gotta say they DO seem to be on the right track with their newest arc gpu line right now... it looks like the return of the mid tier sub-$250 gpu, which is awesome

(especially in light of the rumored nvidia 5080 and 5090 prices which are just absurd)

Post automatically merged:

The irony is that back in2019, I purchased for DE10-NANO for $97 CAD.
Yeah i got 3 of them for $120, but all 3 were stolen in 2022 (bad timing... i dont even have one, now)
 
Last edited:
They've been just a tad bit more expensive than I would like as long as I've been aware and interested in the project, but I did grab myself one of the clones now that they've gone down to around $100-200 for a full system. Haven't regretted that purchase yet to be honest. It's been my go-to for retro games since I got it.

if they lowered the price of the de10 nano to 100 dollars, they would sell 10s of thousands of units... they just dont get it
It's probably just not something ultimately worth focusing to. I'm sure a couple thousand happy retro gamers would be a drop in the bucket in the grand scheme of things for a company as big as intel.
 
It's probably just not something ultimately worth focusing to. I'm sure a couple thousand happy retro gamers would be a drop in the bucket in the grand scheme of things for a company as big as intel.
As i said before in this thread i believe, FPGA's have more use in industrial situations, remember emulation is still a niche, with fpga's being a niche within a niche, intel raised the price because the customers the de10 is focused on would pay it.
 
As i said before in this thread i believe, FPGA's have more use in industrial situations, remember emulation is still a niche, with fpga's being a niche within a niche, intel raised the price because the customers the de10 is focused on would pay it.
The de10 nano is aimed squarely at the computer engineering student market... (for a while after the first price hike there was a discount with a student id)...

it seems like to me, there would be a lot of crossover between ce students and games console enthusiasts. i just think that intel maybe dont see it as a legitimate use case (possibly even consider it to be a borderline illicit use case)

at the same time, i think intel surprised everyone with arc battlemage... so i guess they *do* care about gamers afterall... at least "legitimate" gamers

it will be interesting to see what they do with the new so-called "de25" (agilex 5) series of boards...

i imagine whenever they release a "de 25 nano" that will be the end of the de 10 nano lifecycle... hopefully they will hit a 150 dollar price point, which would be very competitive...
 
Last edited:
While emulation is great for more powerful consoles from 6th gen and up, for me personally, games on: Famicom to N64, SG1000 to Saturn, PC-Engine/CD, PlayStation 1, NeoGeo AES/MVS, NeoGeo Pocket/Color and WonderSwan/Color are done on the MiSTer FPGA. I have a MiSTer MultiSystem on my CRT TV and a traditionnel stack in an aluminum case on my QLED TV.

Other FPGA systems do exists such as The Analogue Pocket for people who are into handhelds as well as Analogue's other FPGA systems. So, are you using FPGA?
what is FPGA?
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Connect with us

Latest Threads

Digimon Story Cyber Sleuth invisible texts bug on vita 3k

The game is working very fine, but there is one problem: some texts in the game are appearing...
Read more

Anime/manga villains

Who is the one villain you hate the most? Or the most annoying for you?
For me it's Shigaraki...
Read more

What is the power difference between a Gameboy Classic and a Color?

I feel that it was barely that different unless you check late gen (aka 2000-2001) games that...
Read more

I.Q.: Intelligent Qube

1738753788503.jpeg


Aka Kurushi in Europe (for some reasons Japan has an english name while Europe got...
Read more

Miss Hokusai 2015

The series is set in the Edo period and covers the careers of the painter Tetsuzo...
Read more

Online statistics

Members online
111
Guests online
233
Total visitors
344

Forum statistics

Threads
3,382
Messages
62,246
Members
219,417
Latest member
fms10pa

Support us

Back
Top