I don't think anyone gives a crap what Kotaku thinks about anything anymore, they made sure of that.
Plenty of good games out this year so far though.
Clair Obscur was good, never finished it though, Ninja Gaiden Ragebound and the new Shinobi are both flat-out great, as was Wuchang until the devs broke its story to placate some remarkably thin-skinned Chinese nationalists and then there's Silksong, of course - haven't had enough time with that game yet, but it's also great so far.
My personal picks currently are actually two early access indies though - Project Silverfish, the best Stalker-like I've ever seen and Jump King Quest, a game I expected to hate but that I've become completely addicted to instead, it's a rage-bait platformer mixed with some Soulsike elements and fuck me I have no idea why, but it works way too well.