Master System Phantasy Star: FM or PSG soundtrack?

xuvetyn96

Paladin Knight
Writers Guild
Level 1
Joined
Dec 13, 2024
Messages
63
Reaction score
170
Points
477
Location
Raccoon City
As I'm sure some of you know, the Sega Master System's Japanese model featured an FM soundchip (the YM2413), while other models had a PSG chip (the SN76489). I've been playing through the original Phantasy Star and I can't decide which one I like more for its soundtrack. The PSG has that great classic, chiptuney retro sound, but I prefer the FM in some places, like the intro (here's the PSG version to compare). So for those who have played this game, what is your favorite way to hear the soundtrack, and, more importantly, why?

EDIT: to add on, I definitely like the PSG battle theme way, way more than the FM one.
 
I like them both, but if i was pushed FM, there is just something nicer sounding about it. Brings me back to when i was a weee wee nipper.
 
I only played Phantasy Star with the PSG sound. Looking at the videos, I prefer the PSG one. When I emulated Wonder Boy III for the first time on Retroarch, FM audio was default. I was trying to figure out why everything sounded so weird compared to what I remembered. It's probably nostalgia bias but I don't like the way FM sounds.
Wonder Boy III PSG
Wonder Boy III FM
 
I think I would go PSG solely because it's what sounds more familiar to me. Had it been the other way around, I'm guessing my preference would too.
That's likely the reason I prefer it too. Some FM soundtracks are so radically different that my brain doesn't process it. Take Kenseiden for example, one of my childhood favorites, give it a listen:

 
That's likely the reason I prefer it too. Some FM soundtracks are so radically different that my brain doesn't process it. Take Kenseiden for example, one of my childhood favorites, give it a listen:
Exactly. I remember the first time I heard the FM for Outrun, thinking that it's definitely good, but once your brain is married to a certain sound with a certain game, it's hard to deviate from that.
 
PSG by a wiiiiide margin for this one. Opening has a slight Phantasy Star 2 vibe in the FM version (in the vein of Prologue, Power, etc.) which makes sense, but otherwise the overload of quiet sine waves where robust PSG sounds should be comes across to me like a page Xeroxed ten times over.
 
Last edited:

Users who are viewing this thread

Connect with us

Featured Video

Phantasy Star Nova (VITA) Translation

Latest Threads

Does anyone here use/frequent Time Extension?

I frequent Time Extension almost daily but I just can't seem to register a profile on the site...
Read more

Nintendo fights against emulator

I think what Nintendo is doing really makes no sense what's the point of fighting against...
Read more

Post your 1CCs here!

Title says it all:
Post your 1CCs (or any proudest gaming achievement for that matter) in this...
Read more

Why people draw a lot of design but only use 1?

Hello! How are you?
I'm a old fan of horror survival and souls like games. I have a lot of art...
Read more

Earthbound vs Mother 3 (a meditation on reserved storytelling)

So, my girlfriend and I have been playing through Mother 3. It’s probably my first time playing...
Read more

Online statistics

Members online
134
Guests online
227
Total visitors
361

Forum statistics

Threads
6,087
Messages
154,481
Members
386,589
Latest member
OniSaka

Support us

Back
Top