Talking Point #2 - Do You Still Collect Physical Games?

IMG_5091.jpeg

In the great digital age, it’s easy to slip into the comfy slippers of your preferred digital storefront. Be it Steam, the PSN store, or whatever option your ecosystem supports. This author in particular owns a number of digital software whose count is in the four digits by now, not counting the hundreds of ROMs stored on two PCs, a phone, and several modded consoles.

We’re at an interesting crossroads where you don’t have to be physical to enjoy some classic retro action; it is perfectly doable to remain strictly digital and not worry about missing out on the vast majority of old-school classics.

This poses an interesting question: Should you continue growing your physical library? We tend to address and provide some consolation while also hoping to hear your experiences on the topic!

Physical Games​

IMG_5097.jpeg

Physical indies are quite cool, you have to admit!
Collecting physical copies of games and growing your library can be a healthy exercise in having a hobby. Being invested in something can feel great, and it’s nice to have some atmosphere while looking at great art.

But understandably, others may think it only comes down to that and nothing more besides preservation, and while that line of thinking is quite reductive, it isn’t hard to see how a person can arrive at this conclusion.

Past and Preservation​

IMG_5112.jpeg

IMG_5092.jpeg

Sometimes owning a game you already like, but in physical form, is really cool!
IMG_5093.jpeg

Or, a historically important game! (That… you also happen to like, of course!)


Perhaps a solid starting point of where owning physical copies becomes highly valuable was in the PS3 era, particularly.

It is rather well-known by now that the PS3 was a really awkward beginning for the digital age; not only did you have to suffer through the pain of a really cool game you wanted to buy only to see it listed as “disc-only,” but the retro PSX-PS2 selection was quite laughable. Don’t forget all the PSP games taunting you for having a system fully capable of running its games but not because Sony was probably never actually ready for the digital transition.

All this combined sets up a lifestyle where you just feel it’s “better” stay physically. Not necessarily due to its positive, but because the supposed “alternative” simply has too many negatives.

But it’s quite nice having these games!​

IMG_5094.jpeg

Best modern racer, don’t @ me.
IMG_5096.jpeg

And best Zelda! I’m making a lot of friends today!

Sometimes it just feels quite nice owning the real thing, doesn’t it? There’s a satisfaction and sense of security that can’t be quite articulated, and that’s good enough for a lot of us. Simply put, a digital copy really doesn’t “feel” quite the same. After a while, you start to realize just how important it is to actually hold something in your hands rather than it being simple pixels on screen.

It’s one of those “if you get it, you get it” kinds of scenarios. While it’s understandable to be content with the other option, as this author made it very clear by confessing to owning a number of digital games that reaches the 4 digits, physical just feels “superior,” not in an elitist sense though. Those who elevate a nerdy hobby into an elitist competition are the real losers; we don’t speak of those.

Now if only there were more space on my shelf…

So, where do we go from here?​

IMG_5095.jpeg

I… might have an Otome addiction…

It is understandable that some may struggle to find appeal in the hobby, specially with most earlier issues getting slowly addressed in the modern digital age. It is much easier now than ever to go fully digital and not worry about inserting cartridges into consoles weaker than your phone, but for a lot of us, a full-digital lifestyle is not entirely sustainable.

There are simply too many games that get delisted with no way of owning them again, too many games that are not really great on emulation and/or require being played on original hardware to have proper cultural context for their game design, and above all else, a goofily engineered handheld device that’s too weak to handle more than 20 GBs at the time without an SD card that needs to be inserted into an opening guarded by a poorly engineered kickstand that can easily snap, leaving the SD slot permanently exposed.

Was this part written with a lot of vitriol towards the big N? But, of course! How could you have a written piece from yours truly not accompanied by some lethal dry snark?

So was this all just an excuse to show off your collection?​

IMG_4433.jpeg

So how do you feel about collecting physical media? Get physical in the comments section below!
 
Last edited:
Physical will always be more open and secure than anything Digital, especially since the 7th Generation of consoles, which were groundbreaking parts of the three major companies' legacies, are now removed (except for the PS3 perhaps). I still hate to know that there are some games I actually know from the 3DS eShop that you cannot get physically and that theyre basically lost media inless you get the game theough other means.
 
Physical will always be more open and secure than anything Digital, especially since the 7th Generation of consoles, which were groundbreaking parts of the three major companies' legacies, are now removed (except for the PS3 perhaps). I still hate to know that there are some games I actually know from the 3DS eShop that you cannot get physically and that theyre basically lost media inless you get the game theough other means.
Truer words, and nice Sage avatar.

Thanks for reading!
 
While I don't go out of my way for that, if I find on a store of on Wallapop a game that looks mildly interesting, I'll probably grab it even if I don't intend to play it. The exception to this is Dragon Quest since I'm building a collection of DQ related stuff.
 
Definitely collect cards, comics and manga more than physical games, but I will always prefer games physically. The ones I really want/love I own physically (My most recent purchase was Metroid Prime Remaster)
As time goes by more and more we see companies (Especially Nintendo) really not understand how important game preservation is, and that's really sad knowing a lot of really incredible retro games will forever be lost
Unless of course you know about emulation, but even then, some people just like to own their favourite retro game legally through official means
 
Nowdays i like the ideia of owning a physical copy of a game, most classic games tend to be quite pricey and in my country until up to the xbox 360/PS3 Era it would be really rare to see someone owning an non-pirated copy of a game since the price would be outta the budget for 80% of the people so pirated games would be the only way to go, in Brazil video-games were always a pretty expensive hobby the consoles it selves would cost a lot of money and expending a third of the price for the console in a single disc sounds like a nightmare, if i could own more copies of games i definitely would
 
Just wake up, now it's time to read this. Yes I collect some physical games from time to time, specially when the game on digital is too big to have it inside the console, one example of this was that I got a lot of PS3 games that were like 24gb like God of War 3, I always thought that finding those games can be fun because there's times where the stores doesn't know what they are selling for example one time I got both Ar Nosurge and Tears to tiara 2 with the art book for 5 dollars each, those has to be the most rare games on my collection with Soul hackers 3DS. I still remember when the major store to get videogames here died and their website became a mess in which you could find these prices
1000303598.jpg

80 dollars for WWE 2K16 ?.
Now that I have the 360 with the magic chip I don't buy a lot of physical games but if I find some cool things there's a possibility that I i'll buy them.
 
To be honest, the cargo cult that so many gamers built around the physical media kinda creeps me out. Ultimately, all the cartridges and discs they worship are simply shells that contain digital files. I can just as easily preserve, say, the entire NGPC library by downloading ROMs onto my hard drive. Not only this is more convenient, but I can also endlessly copy those files, ensuring their longevity.

Oh yeah, I also buy all my Nintendo Switch games physically, but only because Nintendo clearly never heard of adjusting prices according to the region.
 
I did for 25 years and then sold them all. Overall, I went through many years of hearing "you're wasting all your money on games" and then ironically ended up having a lot more in savings in the end after I sold them than most.

But it was a largely pointless endeavour. I had 1000's of games and 95% of them sat gathering dust. Overtime consoles broke, TV situations changed, it just didn't make sense to hold all of these so I stopped collecting and sold out. Never looked back. I sold a lot of them for upwards of $200.

I recently sold my Switch and all the games I had for that too. I bought physicals for that which paid off. I sold most of the games for around the same price I bought them at and some a little more. Like I bought Signalis for £10 new and then 2 years later it was worth £80. So overall, it was way better to buy physicals, because in the end I profited or broke even from just playing games.

It's a waste of money collecting them if you aren't going to sell.

If you are going to collect them then you want to buy from eBay from other gamers. But stores purposefully devalue games by putting stickers on them and too much heavy handling on the cases and sleeves. Plus people who trade games into stores aren't the brightest people so they tend to be more worn than eBay. You will preserve the value of your games that way. But collecting up a bunch of used titles all with stickers on them bought at a discount over time you're going to take up too much space at home then sell them at less than what the games actually worth because the cases are grubby
No hobby is truly harmful. It depends on you the individual, and it appears you had some pretty unhealthy habits.
 
I had some unhealthy habits because I collected video games, kept them in great condition, and sold them off for a profit years down the line?
I’m not sure where this antagonistic tone is coming from. But I don’t think I wanna feed into it. I’ll continue the discussion if there’s honest intentions to converse.
 
Yes when I can and the games does not cost me an arm and a leg.
Very true. I’m kinda glad prices here in kuwait have been reasonable.
Sometimes. Ive been moving things to SSD's. But i do love a thick manual with color in my game cases.
That sounds really nice. Big fan of manuals.
To be honest, the cargo cult that so many gamers built around the physical media kinda creeps me out. Ultimately, all the cartridges and discs they worship are simply shells that contain digital files. I can just as easily preserve, say, the entire NGPC library by downloading ROMs onto my hard drive. Not only this is more convenient, but I can also endlessly copy those files, ensuring their longevity.

Oh yeah, I also buy all my Nintendo Switch games physically, but only because Nintendo clearly never heard of adjusting prices according to the region.
so much truth here. Switch is also my go-to for physical collecting, although it used to be ps4.
While I don't go out of my way for that, if I find on a store of on Wallapop a game that looks mildly interesting, I'll probably grab it even if I don't intend to play it. The exception to this is Dragon Quest since I'm building a collection of DQ related stuff.
I’d absolutely love to see it man. Always admire a good collection. I should collect more manga myself.

Definitely collect cards, comics and manga more than physical games, but I will always prefer games physically. The ones I really want/love I own physically (My most recent purchase was Metroid Prime Remaster)
As time goes by more and more we see companies (Especially Nintendo) really not understand how important game preservation is, and that's really sad knowing a lot of really incredible retro games will forever be lost
Unless of course you know about emulation, but even then, some people just like to own their favourite retro game legally through official means
I need to find the best opportunity to start collecting Digimon cards. Wonder where to start.

Nowdays i like the ideia of owning a physical copy of a game, most classic games tend to be quite pricey and in my country until up to the xbox 360/PS3 Era it would be really rare to see someone owning an non-pirated copy of a game since the price would be outta the budget for 80% of the people so pirated games would be the only way to go, in Brazil video-games were always a pretty expensive hobby the consoles it selves would cost a lot of money and expending a third of the price for the console in a single disc sounds like a nightmare, if i could own more copies of games i definitely would
lots of relatable stuff here.

Just wake up, now it's time to read this. Yes I collect some physical games from time to time, specially when the game on digital is too big to have it inside the console, one example of this was that I got a lot of PS3 games that were like 24gb like God of War 3, I always thought that finding those games can be fun because there's times where the stores doesn't know what they are selling for example one time I got both Ar Nosurge and Tears to tiara 2 with the art book for 5 dollars each, those has to be the most rare games on my collection with Soul hackers 3DS. I still remember when the major store to get videogames here died and their website became a mess in which you could find these prices
View attachment 18665
80 dollars for WWE 2K16 ?.
Now that I have the 360 with the magic chip I don't buy a lot of physical games but if I find some cool things there's a possibility that I i'll buy them.
2K!!! Undelist old WWE games and my life is yours!!
 
I need to find the best opportunity to start collecting Digimon cards. Wonder where to start.
I'm not that deep into Digimon TCG, but usually a good start to collect any card game is pre constructed decks
You can look some up and see which ones have your favourite Digimon in them and could start there
 
I'm not that deep into Digimon TCG, but usually a good start to collect any card game is pre constructed decks
You can look some up and see which ones have your favourite Digimon in them and could start there
My best friend is big on it so I can def ask them. Thanks for your input though!
 
Literally made my first trip to my local retro game store today. I picked up FFIX, Dragon's Dogma, Dark Souls and FFXIII-2. Funny thing about picking up FFXIII-2 is im genuinely an idiot and thought I was getting X-2 instead. Personally, I don't think I'm ever gonna be a guy that has thousands of dollars worth of physical games lining my shelves but I do think that the limits of physical media are a nice reprieve from the onslaught of choices that we're faced with in this digital age.
 
Rarely, as I have Everdrives and ODEs set up for most of my systems, but occasionally I will pick up a NES or SNES game if it is something I always wanted when I was a kid and intend to play.

I did get Rock n Roll Racing for the SNES a couple weeks ago since it was in great condition and was always one of my favorite games growing up. I also picked up reproduction cartridges of Dragon Quest 1&2 and Terranigma when at a gaming convention last year.
 
Literally made my first trip to my local retro game store today. I picked up FFIX, Dragon's Dogma, Dark Souls and FFXIII-2. Funny thing about picking up FFXIII-2 is im genuinely an idiot and thought I was getting X-2 instead. Personally, I don't think I'm ever gonna be a guy that has thousands of dollars worth of physical games lining my shelves but I do think that the limits of physical media are a nice reprieve from the onslaught of choices that we're faced with in this digital age.
Well said. A lot of good points here.
I have the following rules:
  1. If a game is available on discs/cartridge, buy it (console only, obviously)
  2. If not, check GOG and buy there
  3. If not on GOG, check Steam and buy there
Nice rules. Gog is handy. No drm.
Rarely, as I have Everdrives and ODEs set up for most of my systems, but occasionally I will pick up a NES or SNES game if it is something I always wanted when I was a kid and intend to play.

I did get Rock n Roll Racing for the SNES a couple weeks ago since it was in great condition and was always one of my favorite games growing up. I also picked up reproduction cartridges of Dragon Quest 1&2 and Terranigma when at a gaming convention last year.
Sounds like some good game pickups. Nice finds.
 
We're from different worlds. For most of my gaming life physical copies where the only way you could play. So just by proxy of being older I built up a collection, plus of being pretty hardcore, I picked up a lot of valued niche titles like weeby JRPG's that someones always willing to buy.

For games after the 6th generation it's a bit more tenuous. Most of those games like Dragons Dogma can be bought pretty cheap digitally already and they've been patched or come with DLC's that you can't get anymore on old stores like PSN for PS3. They don't hold value because they are remastered or available on newer platforms.

I also used to buy the day one collectors edition of a lot of games as well and they're also becoming a dying breed of product. I had the collectors editions for FF13 and the original Demon's Souls. Nowadays people will pay extra money on day one to pre-order and get extra healing items or money to make the game easier. But it was cool back in the day getting lots of memoribillia, or maybe a special case like the metal Resident Evil 4 case.

Nowadays it feels like you might as well just get the digital version if it's there for the most part. Like I would probably rather get FFX / X2 HD in the one package for cheaper than it is finding the physical copies.

I'll always miss box art and great manulas though for sentimental value those things can't be beaten. I still have my first game ever, Sonic the Hedgehog, that I got when I was 3. Even though I never play it and don't even have a Mega Drive I keep it purely for nostalgia reasons. In the modern times it depends on the game. I was so close to keeping my mint copy of Silent Hill 2 Directors Cut just for the sake of having it but I'd rather have the money. I can always emulate any game pre-2010 anyway with issues being rare now.
Definitely agree that digital is a more convenient and frugal way of consuming video games but I guess I'm just trying to pursue consuming more physical media is just to see if it has any meaningful effect on how I enjoy and value that media. I'm definitely not interested in hunting the rarest stuff (though I am very jealous that you had that mint Silent Hill 2 copy) and would've went for newer, less "valuable" games if it weren't for the fact that I don't own a PS5 and my PS4 has had a broken disc tray for years.

100% get what you're saying about collectors editions and manuals etc. Wasn't really in the position to be getting the cool limited editions when physical copies were still king but I do remember even the basic versions of games having cute little add-ons (I think my copy of Oblivion came with a map of Cyrodill, did they do that for Skyrim?). Definitely would be cool to see that make a resurgence but I couldn't imagine it happening anytime soon .
 
Nowdays I only keep physical copies of games I really really like and are willing to point out and tell others they should consider playing it at least once or to watch a playthrough of it on the tubeyou.

On a side note I really do miss physical game manuals. I watched a streamer flicking through the Zelda II manual on the Switch online service and the artwork and little notes here and there are so wonderful!
 

Users who are viewing this thread

latest_articles

Online statistics

Members online
308
Guests online
191
Total visitors
499

Forum statistics

Threads
5,506
Messages
137,926
Members
340,535
Latest member
Papjeski

Support us

Back
Top